Pragmatism Versus Idealism

One of the central tensions in the play is the struggle between pragmatism and idealism—between the purity of political principles and the compromises necessary to achieve real change. The play explores this theme not only through Nye’s personal journey but also through the radical reading group he was a part of in his youth. These idealists begin by engaging with revolutionary ideas in books, discussing the injustices of capitalism and the need for a more equal society. However, as they become increasingly unhappy with the lack of change around them, they realize that debate alone will not bring about change. Rather than remaining detached intellectuals, they take action, seeking positions on local councils and committees where they can wield real influence. This shift—from theory to practice—mirrors the journey Nye himself undergoes throughout his career as he moves from being an...