Chapters 4 and 5 Summary

In Chapter 4, the Alison and Brenda are at an early-morning rehearsal for the school play, You Can't Take it With You, when a freshman interrupts the rehearsal to announce that everyone should come see something. It is not until Brenda and Alison make it to the gym that they realize what is going on. The school's mascot head has been replaced with a grotesque goat head.

Later, Fran and Alison are talking about the chain letter, and Fran insists to Alison that she has never told anybody about it. Alison believes her, knowing that she is good at keeping secrets. While they are talking, Joan comes up to them looking for Neil and Tony. Alison is sassy with her, and Joan warns her harshly to stay away from Tony.

Tony and Neil appear soon after Joan leaves. While they are talking...