Discussions of An Equal Music are likely to center on Michael Holme himself—his largely unexamined anxieties and his struggle to cope with them—and on Julia's struggles with her growing deafness, with her conscience, and with Michael. Readers might also consider, though, what the minor characters in the novel contribute. How, for instance, do the other three members of the Maggiore compare with Michael? What are the circumstances of their lives, and how does music function for them? Also worthy of attention are Michael's remaining friends and family in Rochdale—not only Mrs. Formby, but Michael's father and Auntie Joan. What roles do they play? Finally, there is much to be said about Seth's portrayal of music as a kind of medicine for the sometimes painful business of living. Is it enough of a consolation? Will Michael eventually be simply happy?

1. In...