Egon Schwartz, demonstrating how the vagaries of Hermann Hesse's reputation have depended on place and time [in "Hermann Hesse, The American Youth Movement, and Problems of Literary Evaluation," PMLA, Vol. 85, 1970], suggests that literary scholarship, even when presuming to be value-free, is constantly reflecting its temporal situation, that it "is replete with unreflected values and engages in indirect evaluation all the time." The example of Hesse, that belatedly acclaimed guru, is surely dramatic; yet, beyond even the unknowntoday, adulated-tomorrow (or vice versa) stereotype, there are many other, more subtle, manifestations of temporal influence on literary scholarship and evaluation.
I shall speak of two. There is, first of all, the simple matter of subject matter. Critics have not sufficiently acknowledged the important role that "subject" plays in determining the literature that they praise or, more subtly,.....
This is a free excerpt of 135 words. This section contains 365 words. This
study guide contains 17,064 words (approx. 57 pages at 300
words per page).
Read the rest of this Literature Guide with our A Spinster's Tale Access Pass.
