Other Voices, Other Rooms

Would Joel be happier if he went back to New Orleans? Does staying at the manor mean he can't grow up?

乔尔应该留在庄园还是回到新奥尔良?

Asked by
Last updated by Cat
1 Answers
Log in to answer

All the important characters in the book have been ostracized by society or are on the outside by circumstances both within and beyond their control. Joel is essentially an orphan due to his mother's death and his father's paralysis. Joel never fits in with his aunt's family and misbehaves as a way of showing resentment for his situation. Joel's father, Edward Sansom, is the most physically isolated character in the book due to his paralysis and inability to communicate. Miss Amy's isolation appears in the form of being married to a paralyzed man with whom she has a caregiver's relationship, not one of love. Randolph is isolated because of his homosexuality with which he comes to terms after the attraction to Pepe Alvarez. As an artist, Randolph shows more sensitivity than most men and feels things deeply, qualities which were probably unattractive to Pepe, whose macho identity would have never entertained any type of relationship with Randolph. Missouri is also isolated because she is a black woman living and working at the Landing located in a remote region of Louisiana. Missouri is a young woman and wants to find a man to love, and especially wants to escape the mental and physical reminders of the husband who brutalized her. Idabel is also an isolated character, partly because of her tomboy mannerisms and also by her burgeoning homosexual tendencies.