The Doctor's Dilemma: Preface on Doctors eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 99 pages of information about The Doctor's Dilemma.

The Doctor's Dilemma: Preface on Doctors eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 99 pages of information about The Doctor's Dilemma.
the danger of inoculating without any reference to the patient’s “opsonic index” at the moment of inoculation, and though those other doctors who are denouncing the danger as imaginary and opsonin as a craze or a fad, obviously do so because it involves an operation which they have neither the means nor the knowledge to perform, there is still no grasp of the economic change in the situation.  They have never been warned that the practicability of any method of extirpating disease depends not only on its efficacy, but on its cost.  For example, just at present the world has run raving mad on the subject of radium, which has excited our credulity precisely as the apparitions at Lourdes excited the credulity of Roman Catholics.  Suppose it were ascertained that every child in the world could be rendered absolutely immune from all disease during its entire life by taking half an ounce of radium to every pint of its milk.  The world would be none the healthier, because not even a Crown Prince—­no, not even the son of a Chicago Meat King, could afford the treatment.  Yet it is doubtful whether doctors would refrain from prescribing it on that ground.  The recklessness with which they now recommend wintering in Egypt or at Davos to people who cannot afford to go to Cornwall, and the orders given for champagne jelly and old port in households where such luxuries must obviously be acquired at the cost of stinting necessaries, often make one wonder whether it is possible for a man to go through a medical training and retain a spark of common sense.  This sort of inconsiderateness gets cured only in the classes where poverty, pretentious as it is even at its worst, cannot pitch its pretences high enough to make it possible for the doctor (himself often no better off than the patient) to assume that the average income of an English family is about 2,000 pounds a year, and that it is quite easy to break up a home, sell an old family seat at a sacrifice, and retire into a foreign sanatorium devoted to some “treatment” that did not exist two years ago and probably will not exist (except as a pretext for keeping an ordinary hotel) two years hence.  In a poor practice the doctor must find cheap treatments for cheap people, or humiliate and lose his patients either by prescribing beyond their means or sending them to the public hospitals.  When it comes to prophylactic inoculation, the alternative lies between the complete scientific process, which can only be brought down to a reasonable cost by being very highly organized as a public service in a public institution, and such cheap, nasty, dangerous and scientifically spurious imitations as ordinary vaccination, which seems not unlikely to be ended, like its equally vaunted forerunner, XVIII. century inoculation, by a purely reactionary law making all sorts of vaccination, scientific or not, criminal offences.  Naturally, the poor doctor (that is, the average doctor) defends ordinary vaccination frantically, as it means to him
Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
The Doctor's Dilemma: Preface on Doctors from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.