A Treatise of Human Nature eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 785 pages of information about A Treatise of Human Nature.

A Treatise of Human Nature eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 785 pages of information about A Treatise of Human Nature.

This deficiency in our ideas is not, indeed, perceived in common life, nor are we sensible, that in the most usual conjunctions of cause and effect we are as ignorant of the ultimate principle, which binds them together, as in the most unusual and extraordinary.  But this proceeds merely from an illusion of the imagination; and the question is, how far we ought to yield to these illusions.  This question is very difficult, and reduces us to a very dangerous dilemma, whichever way we answer it.  For if we assent to every trivial suggestion of the fancy; beside that these suggestions are often contrary to each other; they lead us into such errors, absurdities, and obscurities, that we must at last become ashamed of our credulity.  Nothing is more dangerous to reason than the flights of the imagination, and nothing has been the occasion of more mistakes among philosophers.  Men of bright fancies may in this respect be compared to those angels, whom the scripture represents as covering their eyes with their wings.  This has already appeared in so many instances, that we may spare ourselves the trouble of enlarging upon it any farther.

But on the other hand, if the consideration of these instances makes us take a resolution to reject all the trivial suggestions of the fancy, and adhere to the understanding, that is, to the general and more established properties of the imagination; even this resolution, if steadily executed, would be dangerous, and attended with the most fatal consequences.  For I have already shewn [Sect. 1.], that the understanding, when it acts alone, and according to its most general principles, entirely subverts itself, and leaves not the lowest degree of evidence in any proposition, either in philosophy or common life.  We save ourselves from this total scepticism only by means of that singular and seemingly trivial property of the fancy, by which we enter with difficulty into remote views of things, and are not able to accompany them with so sensible an impression, as we do those, which are more easy and natural.  Shall we, then, establish it for a general maxim, that no refined or elaborate reasoning is ever to be received?  Consider well the consequences of such a principle.  By this means you cut off entirely all science and philosophy:  You proceed upon one singular quality of the imagination, and by a parity of reason must embrace all of them:  And you expressly contradict yourself; since this maxim must be built on the preceding reasoning, which will be allowed to be sufficiently refined and metaphysical.  What party, then, shall we choose among these difficulties?  If we embrace this principle, and condemn all refined reasoning, we run into the most manifest absurdities.  If we reject it in favour of these reasonings, we subvert entirely the, human understanding.  We have, therefore, no choice left but betwixt a false reason and none at all.  For my part, know not what ought to be done in the present case.  I can only observe what is commonly done; which is, that this difficulty is seldom or never thought of; and even where it has once been present to the mind, is quickly forgot, and leaves but a small impression behind it.  Very refined reflections have little or no influence upon us; and yet we do not, and cannot establish it for a rule, that they ought not to have any influence; which implies a manifest contradiction.

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
A Treatise of Human Nature from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.