But the careful investigation which he recommended did not fall in with the particular genius and uncritical methods of Foxe, who, perhaps on account of his necessitous condition, worked away with a will on the unsifted tales and reports as they came to hand, so that the book in its Latin form was completed, almost to the end of the reign of Mary, and was published at Basle, before his return to England in 1559.  He afterwards made an English translation of the work, but without seeing fit to revise his material.  It bore the title Acts and Monuments, but it was at once popularly styled the Book of Martyrs.  When he was attacked by Alan Cope (Nicholas Harpsfield) for his inaccuracy, Foxe replied:  “I hear what you will say:  I should have taken more leisure and done it better.  I grant and confess my fault, such is my vice, I cannot sit all the day (Moister Cope) fining and mincing my letters, and combing my head, and smoothing myself all the day at the glass of Cicero.  Yet, notwithstanding, doing what I can, and doing my good will, methinks I should not be reprehended, at least not so much be railed of at M. Copes hand."**

* Strype, Life of Archbishop Grindal, p. 25.

** Acts and Monuments, i. 69 1.  Edited 1570.

But it is not for his want of scholarly writing that Foxe has been blamed.  Father Robert Persons, in his Three Conversions of England,* begins one of his chapters with “a note of more than a hundred and twenty lies uttered by John Foxe, in less than three leaves of his Acts and Monuments,” and he proceeds to point them out, beginning with the misstatement concerning John Merbeck and some others, whom Foxe counts among the martyrs, although they were never burned at all.  As, in consequence of Father Persons’ remarks concerning John Merbeck, Foxe acknowledged the error in his second edition, we may hold him excused thus far, but his delinquencies in this respect were by no means unfrequent, and gave rise to the saying that “many who were burnt in the reign of Queen Mary, drank sack in the reign of Queen Elizabeth."**

* Quoted in Fuller’s Worthies, under “Berkshire,” p. 92.

Part iii., p. 412.”

Two similar misstatements, which he was in a position to correct and did not, relate to the supposed death by the vengeance of God, of Henry Morgan, Bishop of St. David’s, and of one Grimwood, another “notorious Papist.”

Anthony a Wood, the famous antiquary and historian, who wrote his History of the Antiquities of Oxford about a hundred years after Foxe had become celebrated as a martyrologist, and who in his youth spoke with people who remembered the days of persecution under Mary, tells us that:—­