Joe Welling’s love affair set the town of Winesburg on edge.  When it began everyone whispered and shook his head.  When people tried to laugh, the laughter was forced and unnatural.  Joe fell in love with Sarah King, a lean, sad-looking woman who lived with her father and brother in a brick house that stood opposite the gate leading to the Winesburg Cemetery.

The two Kings, Edward the father, and Tom the son, were not popular in Winesburg.  They were called proud and dangerous.  They had come to Winesburg from some place in the South and ran a cider mill on the Trunion Pike.  Tom King was reported to have killed a man before he came to Winesburg.  He was twenty-seven years old and rode about town on a grey pony.  Also he had a long yellow mustache that dropped down over his teeth, and always carried a heavy, wicked-looking walking stick in his hand.  Once he killed a dog with the stick.  The dog belonged to Win Pawsey, the shoe merchant, and stood on the sidewalk wagging its tail.  Tom King killed it with one blow.  He was arrested and paid a fine of ten dollars.

Old Edward King was small of stature and when he passed people in the street laughed a queer unmirthful laugh.  When he laughed he scratched his left elbow with his right hand.  The sleeve of his coat was almost worn through from the habit.  As he walked along the street, looking nervously about and laughing, he seemed more dangerous than his silent, fierce-looking son.

When Sarah King began walking out in the evening with Joe Welling, people shook their heads in alarm.  She was tall and pale and had dark rings under her eyes.  The couple looked ridiculous together.  Under the trees they walked and Joe talked.  His passionate eager protestations of love, heard coming out of the darkness by the cemetery wall, or from the deep shadows of the trees on the hill that ran up to the Fair Grounds from Waterworks Pond, were repeated in the stores.  Men stood by the bar in the New Willard House laughing and talking of Joe’s courtship.  After the laughter came the silence.  The Winesburg baseball team, under his management, was winning game after game, and the town had begun to respect him.  Sensing a tragedy, they waited, laughing nervously.

Late on a Saturday afternoon the meeting between Joe Welling and the two Kings, the anticipation of which had set the town on edge, took place in Joe Welling’s room in the New Willard House.  George Willard was a witness to the meeting.  It came about in this way: 

When the young reporter went to his room after the evening meal he saw Tom King and his father sitting in the half darkness in Joe’s room.  The son had the heavy walking stick in his hand and sat near the door.  Old Edward King walked nervously about, scratching his left elbow with his right hand.  The hallways were empty and silent.

George Willard went to his own room and sat down at his desk.  He tried to write but his hand trembled so that he could not hold the pen.  He also walked nervously up and down.  Like the rest of the town of Winesburg he was perplexed and knew not what to do.