Now, after they had read and considered the letter, they consulted what answer to return; and the first that did speak to it was Lucifer.

Then said he, ’The first project of the Diabolonians in Mansoul is likely to be lucky, and to take; namely, that they will, by all the ways and means they can, make Mansoul yet more vile and filthy:  no way to destroy a soul like this.  Our old friend Balaam went this way and prospered many years ago; let this therefore stand with us for a maxim, and be to Diabolonians for a general rule in all ages; for nothing can make this to fail but grace, in which I would hope that this town has no share.  But whether to fall upon them on a market-day, because of their cumber in business, that I would should be under debate.  And there is more reason why this head should be debated, than why some other should; because upon this will turn the whole of what we shall attempt.  If we time not our business well, our whole project may fail.  Our friends, the Diabolonians, say that a market-day is best; for then will Mansoul be most busy, and have fewest thoughts of a surprise.  But what if also they should double their guards on those days? (and methinks nature and reason should teach them to do it;) and what if they should keep such a watch on those days as the necessity of their present case doth require? yea, what if their men should be always in arms on those days? then you may, my lords, be disappointed in your attempts, and may bring our friends in the town to utter danger of unavoidable ruin.’

Then said the great Beelzebub, ’There is something in what my lord hath said; but his conjecture may, or may not fall out.  Nor hath my lord laid it down as that which must not be receded from; for I know that he said it only to provoke to a warm debate thereabout.  Therefore we must understand, if we can, whether the town of Mansoul has such sense and knowledge of her decayed state, and of the design that we have on foot against her, as doth provoke her to set watch and ward at her gates, and to double them on market-days.  But if, after inquiry made, it shall be found that they are asleep, then any day will do, but a market-day is best; and this is my judgment in this case.’

Then quoth Diabolus, ‘How should we know this?’ and it was answered, ‘Inquire about it at the mouth of Mr. Profane.’  So Profane was called in, and asked the question, and he made his answer as follows:-

Prof.  My lords, so far as I can gather, this is at present the condition of the town of Mansoul:  they are decayed in their faith and love; Emmanuel, their Prince, has given them the back; they send often by petition to fetch him again, but he maketh not haste to answer their request, nor is there much reformation among them.

Diab.  I am glad that they are backward in a reformation, but yet I am afraid of their petitioning.  However, their looseness of life is a sign that there is not much heart in what they do, and without the heart things are little worth.  But go on, my masters; I will divert you, my lords, no longer.