Colonel Starbottle had to be lifted from the cart.  “This yer camp is played out,” he said, gloomily, as he affected to be supported into the Magnolia.  With what further expression he might have indicated his feelings it was impossible to say, for at that moment Scott joined the group.  “Did you speak to me?” he asked of the Colonel, dropping his hand, as if with accidental familiarity, on that gentleman’s shoulder.  The Colonel, recognizing some occult quality in the touch, and some unknown quantity in the glance of his questioner, contented himself by replying, “No, sir,” with dignity.  A few rods away, York’s conduct was as characteristic and peculiar.  “You had a mighty fine chance; why didn’t you plump him?” said Jack Hamlin, as York drew near the buggy.  “Because I hate him,” was the reply, heard only by Jack.  Contrary to popular belief, this reply was not hissed between the lips of the speaker, but was said in an ordinary tone.  But Jack Hamlin, who was an observer of mankind, noticed that the speaker’s hands were cold, and his lips dry, as he helped him into the buggy, and accepted the seeming paradox with a smile.

When Sandy Bar became convinced that the quarrel between York and Scott could not be settled after the usual local methods, it gave no further concern thereto.  But presently it was rumored that the “Amity Claim” was in litigation, and that its possession would be expensively disputed by each of the partners.  As it was well known that the claim in question was “worked out” and worthless, and that the partners, whom it had already enriched, had talked of abandoning it but a day or two before the quarrel, this proceeding could only be accounted for as gratuitous spite.  Later, two San Francisco lawyers made their appearance in this guileless Arcadia, and were eventually taken into the saloons, and—­what was pretty much the same thing—­the confidences of the inhabitants.  The results of this unhallowed intimacy were many subpoenas; and, indeed, when the “Amity Claim” came to trial, all of Sandy Bar that was not in compulsory attendance at the county seat came there from curiosity.  The gulches and ditches for miles around were deserted.  I do not propose to describe that already famous trial.  Enough that, in the language of the plaintiff’s counsel, “it was one of no ordinary significance, involving the inherent rights of that untiring industry which had developed the Pactolian resources of this golden land”; and, in the homelier phrase of Colonel Starbottle, “A fuss that gentlemen might hev settled in ten minutes over a social glass, ef they meant business; or in ten seconds with a revolver, ef they meant fun.”  Scott got a verdict, from which York instantly appealed.  It was said that he had sworn to spend his last dollar in the struggle.