Inquiries and Opinions eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 223 pages of information about Inquiries and Opinions.

Inquiries and Opinions eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 223 pages of information about Inquiries and Opinions.

Even tho no German can sustain a claim to supremacy in the drama, it is to the Germans that the consent of the whole world now awards the incontestable supremacy in the sister art of music.  To the race that gave birth to Bach and Beethoven, to Mozart and Schubert and Wagner, it matters little whether the chiefs of music number two only, or whether they may be so many as four or five.  Indeed, it may be admitted at once that the list would need to be widely extended before it would include the name of any composer who was not a scion of the Teutonic stock.

There is a certain significance, also, in the probability that the outsider who could best justify a claim for inclusion would be a Russian rather than an Italian or a Frenchman.  And this estimate, it may be well to confess, is not personal to the present writer, who has no skill in music and scant acquaintance with its intricacies; it is the outcome of a disinterested endeavor to discover the consensus of expert opinion, free from any racial bias.

But the northern races who excel in the art of the musician seem to be inferior to the southern in the arts of the painter and of the sculptor,—­more particularly in the latter.  The supreme sculptors are apparently two or three:  Phidias and Michelangelo, beyond all question, and with them probably we ought also to place Donatello.  Of Praxiteles we know too little.  Of most other artists in marble and in bronze we know too much, however fine their occasional achievements,—­Verrocchio’s ‘Colleoni,’ for example.  They do not sustain themselves at the lofty level on which Michelangelo moves with certainty and ease—­“the greatest of known artists,” so Mr. Lafarge has ventured to acclaim him; and just as Shakspere is unsurpassed as a poet and also as a playwright, just as Cicero takes a foremost place as an orator and also as a writer of prose, so Michelangelo is mighty as a sculptor, as an architect, and as a painter.

As a painter he has more rivals than as a sculptor.  We may limit the supreme masters of the plastic art to two, or to three at the most; but the supreme masters of the pictorial art are twice three, at the very least.  By the side of Michelangelo there is Raphael, also an Italian; and has any one really a right to exclude Titian from their fellowship?  Then there are Velasquez, the Spaniard, and Duerer, the German.  And farther north in the Netherlands, there are Rembrandt and Rubens; and ought not Vandyke to be allowed to stand aloft with them?  Six, at the lowest count, and eight by the more liberal estimate, are the men who have gone to the forefront in the art of the brush, half of them from the north and half of them from the south; and among them all not one who had English for his native speech, and not one whose mother-tongue was French.  Indeed, at least one German, Holbein, and two or three more Italians would be admitted within the sacred enclosure before any Frenchman or any Englishman could have free entry.

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
Inquiries and Opinions from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.