as we did willingly or voluntarily or with pleasure
or joy. It was hard enough for our hearts, but
we could not prevent it, we thought to give his conscience
such counsel as we could.—I have indeed
learned several confessional secrets, both while I
was still a papist and later, which, if they were
revealed, I should live to deny or else publish the
whole confession. Such things belong not to the
secular courts, nor are they to be published.
God has here His own judgment, and must counsel souls
in matters where no worldly law nor wisdom can help.
My preceptor in the cloister, a fine old man, had
many such affairs, and once had to say of them with
a sigh: ’Alas, alas! such things are so
perplexed and desperate that no wisdom, law, nor reason
can avail; one must commend them to divine goodness.’
So instructed, I have, accordingly, in this case also
acted agreeably to divine goodness.—But
had I known that the Landgrave had long before satisfied
his desires, and could well satisfy them with others,
as I have now just learned that he did with her of
Eschwege, truly no angel would have induced me to give
such counsel. I gave it only in consideration
of his unavoidable necessity and weakness, and to
put his conscience out of peril, as Bucer represented
the case to me. Much less would I ever have advised
that there should be a public marriage, to which (though
he told me nothing of this) a young princess and young
countess should come, which is truly not to be borne
and is insufferable to the whole empire. But
I understood and hoped, as long as he had to go the
common way with sin and shame and weakness of the
flesh, that he would take some honorable maiden or
other in secret marriage, even if the relation did
not have a legal look before the world. My concession
was on account of the great need of his conscience—such
as happened to other great lords. In like manner
I advised certain priests in the Catholic lands of
Duke George and the bishops secretly to marry their
cooks.—This was my confessional counsel
about which I would much rather have kept silence,
but it has been wrung from me, and I could do nothing
but speak. But the men of Dresden speak as though
I had taught the same for thirteen years, and yet they
give us to understand what a friendly heart they have
to us, and what great desire for love and unity, just
as if there were no scandal or sin in their lives,
which are ten times worse before God than anything
I ever advised. But the world must always smugly
rail at the moat in its neighbor’s eye, and
forget the beam in its own eye. If I must defend
all I have said or done in former years, especially
at the beginning, I must beg the Pope to do the same,
for if they defend their former acts (let alone their
present ones), they would belong to the devil more
than to God.—I am not ashamed of my counsel,
even if it should be published in all the world; but
for the sake of the unpleasantness which would then
follow, I should prefer, if possible, to have kept
it secret. Martin Luther, with his own hand.”
(21b, 2467; transl. by Preserved Smith.)


