day coals were discovered under the stables of a Mr.
John Murray on Broadway. On the next morning
an alarm called the people to the residence of Sergeant
Burns, near the fort; and in a few hours the dwelling
of a Mr. Hilton, near Fly Market, was found to be
on fire. But the flames in both places were readily
extinguished. It was thought that the fire was
purposely set at Mr. Hilton’s, as a bundle of
tow was found near the premises. A short time
before these strange fires broke out, a Spanish vessel,
partly manned by Spanish Catholic Negroes, had been
brought into the port of New York as a prize.
All the crew that were Negroes were hurried into the
Admiralty Court; where they were promptly condemned
to slavery, and an order issued for their sale.
The Negroes pleaded their freedom in another country,
but had no counsel to defend them. A Capt.
Sarly purchased one of these Negroes. Now, Capt.
Sarly’s house adjoined that of Mr. Hilton’s;
and so, when the latter’s house was discovered
to be on fire, a cry was raised, “The Spanish
Negroes! The Spanish! Take up the Spanish
Negroes!” Some persons took it upon themselves
to question Capt. Sarly’s Negro about the
fires, and it is said that he behaved in an insolent
manner; whereupon he was sent to jail. A magistrate
gave orders to the constables to arrest and incarcerate
the rest of the Spanish Negroes. The magistrates
held a meeting the same day, in the afternoon; and,
while they were deliberating about the matter, another
fire broke out in Col. Phillipes’s storehouse.
Some of the white people cried “Negro!
Negro!” and “Cuff Phillipes!” Poor
Cuff, startled at the cry, ran to his master’s
house, from whence he was dragged to jail by an excited
mob. Judge Horsemanden says,—
“Many people had such terrible
apprehensions on this occasion that several Negroes
(many of whom had assisted to put out the fire)
who were met in the streets, were hurried away
to jail; and when they were there they were continued
some time in confinement before the magistrates
could spare time to examine into their several
cases."[244]
Let the reader return now to the robbery committed
in Mr. Hogg’s house on the 28th of February.
The officers thought they had traced the stolen goods
to a public house on the North River, kept by a person
named John Hughson. This house had been a place
of resort for Negroes; and it was searched for the
articles, but nothing was found. Hughson had
in his service an indentured servant,—a
girl of sixteen years,—named Mary Burton.
She intimated to a neighbor that the goods were concealed
in Hughson’s house, but that it would be at the
expense of her life to make this fact known.
This information was made known to the sheriff, and
he at once apprehended the girl and produced her before
Alderman Banker. This benevolent officer promised
the girl her freedom on the ground that she should
tell all she knew about the missing property.
For prudential reasons the Alderman ordered Mary Burton