“It was a maxim of that excellent divine,” said he, “that Christian censure should never be used to make a sinner desperate; for then he either sinks under the burden or grows impudent and tramples upon it.  A charitable modest remedy, says he, preserves that which is virtue’s girdle-fear and blushing.  Honour, dear lad, is the peculiar counsellor of well-bred natures, and these are few; but almost in all men you will find a certain modesty toward sin, and were I a king my judges should be warned that their duty is to chasten; whereas by punishing immoderately they can but effect the exact opposite.”

We found our trio waiting for us on the far side of the square; and, having fetched our horses and left an order at the inn for Billy Priske on his return to mount and follow us, wended our way out of the town.  The streets on this side were deserted and mournful, the shopkeepers having fastened their shutters for fear of the mob, of whose present doings no sound reached us but a faint murmuring hubbub borne on the afternoon air from the northward—­that is, from the direction of the Green Bank and the Penryn Road.

My father led the way at a foot’s pace, and seemed to ride pondering, for his chin was sunk on his chest and he had pulled his hat-brim well over his eyes (but this may have been against the July sun).  After him tramped Mr. Fett in eager converse with the little pawnbroker, now questioning him, now halting to regard him, as a man who has dug up a sudden treasure and for the moment can only gaze at it and hug himself.  Nat and I brought up the rear, he striding at my stirrup and pouring forth the tale of his adventures since we parted.  A dozen times he rehearsed the scene of the parental quarrel, and interrupted each rehearsal with a dozen anxious questions.  “Ought he to have given this answer?—­to have uttered that defiance?  Did I think he had shown self-control; Had he treated the old gentleman with becoming respect?  Would I put myself in his place?  Suppose it had been my own father, now—­”

“But yours, lad, is a father in a thousand,” he broke off bitterly.  “I had never a notion that father and son could be friends, as are you and he.  He is splendid—­splendid!”

I glanced at him quickly and turned my face aside, suspecting that he took my father for a madman, and was kindly concealing the discovery.  Nevertheless I hardened my voice to answer—­

“You will say so when you know him better.  And my Uncle Gervase runs him a good second.”

“Faith, then, I wish you’d persuade your uncle to adopt me.  I’m not envious, Prosper, in a general way, but your luck gives me a duced orphanly feeling.  Have I been over-hasty?  That is the question; whether ’twas nobler in the mind to suffer the slings and arrows of accusing conscience or to up and have it out with the old man.”

“Pardon me, gentlemen”—­Mr. Fett wheeled about suddenly on the road ahead of us—­“but it was by accident that I overheard you, and by a singular coincidence at that moment I happened to be discussing the same subject with Mr. Badcock here.”