The Religions of India eBook

Edward Washburn Hopkins
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 825 pages of information about The Religions of India.

The Religions of India eBook

Edward Washburn Hopkins
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 825 pages of information about The Religions of India.
to Cankara all difference is illusion; while according to R[=a]m[=a]nuja brahma is not homogeneous, but in the diversity of the world about us he is truly manifested.  Cankara’s m[=a]y[=a] is R[=a]m[=a]nuja’s body of (brahma) the Lord.  Cankara’s personal god exists only by collusion with illusion, and hence is illusory.  The brahma of R[=a]m[=a]nuja is a personal god, the omnipotent, omniscient, Lord of a real world.  Moreover, from an eschatological point of view, Cankara explains salvation, the release from re-birth, sams[=a]ra, as complete union with this unqualified brahma, consequently as loss of individuality as well as loss of happiness.  But R[=a]m[=a]nuja defines salvation as the departure from earth forever of the individual spirit, which enters a heaven where it will enjoy perennial bliss[65].

R[=a]m[=a]nuja’s doctrine inspires the sectarian pantheism of the present time.  In this there is a metaphysical basis of conduct, a personal god to be loved or feared, the hope of bliss hereafter.  In its essential features it is a very old belief, far older than the philosophy which formulates it[66].  Thus, after the hard saying “fools desire heaven,” this desire reasserted itself, and under R[=a]m[=a]nuja’s genial interpretation of the Ved[=a]nta S[=u]tras the pious man was enabled to build up his cheerful hope again, withal on the basis of a logic as difficult to controvert as was that of Cankara himself[67].

Thus far the product of Vedantism is deism.  But now with two steps one arrives at the inner portal of sectarianism.  First, if brahma is a personal god, which of the gods is he, this personal All-spirit?  As a general thing the Vedantist answers, ‘he is Vishnu’; and adds, ’Vishnu, who embraces as their superior those other gods, Civa, and Brahm[=a].’  But the sectary is not content with making the All-god one with Vishnu.  Vishnu was manifested in the flesh, some say as Krishna, some say as R[=a]ma[68].  The relation of sectary to Vishnuite, and to the All-spirit deist, may be illustrated most clearly by comparison with Occidental religions.  One may not acknowledge any personal god as the absolute Supreme Power; again, one may say that this Supreme Power is a personal god, Jehovah; again, Jehovah may or may not be regarded as one with Christ.  The minuter ramifications of the Christian church then correspond to the sub-sects of Krishnaism or Ramaism.[69]

The Occidental and Oriental conceptions of the trinity are, however, not identical.  For in India the trinity, from the Vishnuite point of view, is an amalgamation of Civa and Brahm[=a] with Vishnu, irrespective of the question whether Vishnu be manifest in Krishna or not; while the Christian trinity amalgamates the form that corresponds to Vishnu with the one that corresponds to Krishna.[70] To the orthodox Brahman, on the other hand, as Williams has very well put it, Krishna is an incarnation of Vishnu, who is himself only an incarnation, that is, a form, of God.

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
The Religions of India from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.