“You make me shockingly weary of my work,” he answered.  “At times I wish I could stop making a labor of religion, and enjoy it a little.  How pleasant it would be to go off to Japan together and fill our sketch-books with drawings.”

This suggestion came on Esther so suddenly that she forgot herself and gave a little cry of delight.  “Oh, are you in earnest?” she said.  “It seems to me that I could crawl and swim there if you would go with me.”

Then she saw her mistake.  Her outburst of pleasure gave him pain.  He was displeased with himself for speaking so thoughtlessly, for this idea of escape made both of them conscious of the chasm on whose edge they stood.

“No, I wish I could be in earnest,” he answered, “but I have just begun work, and there is no vacation for me.  You must keep up my courage.  Without your help I shall break down.”

If he had thought out in advance some device for distressing her, he could not have succeeded better.  She had just time to realize the full strength of her love for him, when he thrust the church between them, and bade her love him for its sake.  The delight of wandering through the world by his side flashed on her mind only to show a whole Fifth Avenue congregation as her rival.  The conviction that the church was hateful to her and that she could never trust herself to obey or love it, forced itself on her at the very moment when she felt that life was nothing without her lover, and that to give up all the world besides in order to go with him, would be the only happiness she cared to ask of her destiny.  The feeling was torture.  So long as he remained she controlled it, but when he went away she wrung her hands in despair and asked herself again and again what she could do; whether she was not going mad with the strain of these emotions.

Before she had fairly succeeded in calming herself, her aunt came to take her out for their daily drive.  Since her father’s death, this drive with her aunt, or a walk with Catherine, had been her only escape from the confinement of the house, and she depended on it more than on food and drink.  They went first to some shops where Mrs. Murray had purchases to make, and Esther sat alone in the carriage while her aunt was engaged within in buying whatever household articles were on her list for the day.  As Esther, sitting quietly in the corner of the carriage, mechanically watched the passers-by, she saw the familiar figure of Mr. Wharton among them, and, with a sudden movement of her old vivacity, she bent forward, caught his eye, and held out her hand.  He stopped before the carriage window, and spoke with more than common cordiality.

“I wanted to come and see you, but I heard you received no one.”

“I will always see you,” she replied.

Looking more than ever shy and embarrassed he said that he should certainly come as soon as his work would let him, and meanwhile he wanted her to know how glad he was to be able at last to offer his congratulations.