Now if you really jot down the merry gossip, and make bright little pen portraits, and tell just what happens, it will not only afford you a deal of discreet amusement, but the diary you keep will reciprocate.  In your older years it will keep you. Harper’s Magazine will undoubtedly want to publish it, forty years from now.  If that is too late to keep you, it will help to keep your descendants.  So I wish some of the authors would confess and let us know which of them are doing it.  It would be jolly to know to whom we might confide the genial little items of what-not and don’t-let-this-go-farther that come the rounds.  The inside story of the literature of any epoch is best told in the diaries.  I’ll bet Brander Matthews kept one, and James Huneker.  It’s a pity Professor Matthews’s was a bit tedious.  Crabb Robinson was the man for my money.

The diarists I would choose for the present generation on Grub Street would be Heywood Broun, Franklin Adams, Bob Holliday, William McFee, and maybe Ben De Casseres (if he would promise not to mention Don Marquis and Walt Whitman more than once per page).  McFee might be let off the job by reason of his ambrosial letters.  But it just occurs to me that of course one must not know who is keeping the diary.  If it were known, he would be deluged with letters from people wanting to get their names into it.  And the really worthwhile folks would be on their guard.

But if all the writers wait until they are eighty years old and can write their memoirs with the beautifully gnarled and chalky old hands Joyce Kilmer loved to contemplate, they will have forgotten the comical pith of a lot of it.  If you want to reproduce the colors and collisions along the sunny side of Grub Street, you’ve got to jot down your data before they fade.  I wish I had time to be diarist of such matters.  How candid I’d be!  I’d put down all about the two young novelists who used to meet every day in City Hall Park to compare notes while they were hunting for jobs, and make wagers as to whose pair of trousers would last longer. (Quite a desirable essay could he written, by the way, on the influence of trousers on the fortunes of Grub Street, with the three stages of the Grub Street trouser, viz.:  1, baggy; 2, shiny; 3, trousers that must not be stooped in on any account.) There is an uproarious tale about a pair of trousers and a very well-known writer and a lecture at Vassar College, but these things have to be reserved for posterity, the legatee of all really amusing matters.

But then there are other topics, too, such as the question whether Ibanez always wears a polo shirt, as the photos lead one to believe.  The secret Philip Gibbs told me about the kind of typewriter he used on the western front.  I would be enormously candid (if I were a diarist).  I’d put down that I never can remember whether Vida Scudder is a man or a woman.  I’d tell what A. Edward Newton said when he came rushing into the office to