easily out of its severer lines. What resistless
magic is there in the fingers whose touch upon the
same rich banks of keys, summons solemn, vibrant peals
as of Beethoven’s grandest fugues, endless harmonies
as of the deep seas, and the light and graceful fantasies
of Rossini, which are as the glad sunshine upon their
waves. Truly the poet’s gift is a divine
and an awful one. His heart must needs be proud
and humble too, who is claimed as nearer of kin than
a brother by myriads of stranger souls, each, perhaps,
owning its separate creed, and in whose unspoken prayers
his name is ever present. In his ’Conversations
on some of the old Poets,’ we discover the alembic
through which his crude opinions, his glowing impulses,
his exquisitely minute discrimination were distilled;—the
old poets, to whom the heart turns ever lovingly as
to the wide west at eve. They were the nursing
mothers of his intellectual infancy, and it is probably
to his reverent but not blind esteem for them, his
earnest study of them, not merely as poets, but as
men, citizens, and friends, that much of the buoyancy
and vigor of his poetry is to be attributed.
The ‘Conversations’ themselves are alive
with that enthusiasm and sympathetic inquiry that
disproves the false saying of the Parisian Aspasia
of Landor—’Poets are soon too old
for mutual love.’ They are the warm photographs
of feeling as it bubbles from a burning heart; sometimes
burned over-deep, with a leaning to fanaticism, but
with so much of the generosity and justice of maturity
in their decisions that these necessary errors of
an ardent youth are overlooked, and the more as they
have disappeared almost entirely from the productions
of later years. He betrays in his quick conception
of an author’s mood and meaning a delicacy so
extreme, an organization so nervously alive to beauties
and discords, and a religious sentiment so cultured
to the last degree of feeling, that we dread lest we
shall encounter the weakness, morbidness or bigotry
that naturally results from the contact of such a
soul with the passions of everyday life, recalling
the oft-quoted ’Medio in fonte leporum’—
’In the bowl where pleasures swim,
The bitter rises to the brim,
And roses from the veriest brake
May press the temples till they ache.’
But among the roses of his criticisms we look in vain for thorns. In style, it is true, these essays are halting and unequal. His adoption of the colloquial form for the expression of opinion to the public has never seemed to us remarkably felicitous, in spite of its venerable precedents. Where his imagery becomes lofty and his flow of thought should be continuous, we are indignant at its sudden arrest, and involuntarily devote the intruder to a temporary bungalow in Timbuctoo.


