The crowd, triumphant, dispersed.  The organization of the reformers slackened, for they thought that victory was won.  Then the Conservative party landed some of its heaviest blows.  The reformers were accused of desiring to establish a republic.  Dissension was created in their ranks by the promotion of a scheme to recall Pak Yung-hio.  Some of the more extreme Independents indulged in wild talk, and gave excuse for official repression.  Large numbers of reform leaders were arrested on various pretexts.  Meetings were dispersed at the point of the bayonet, and the reform movement was broken.  The Emperor did not realize that he had, in the hour that he consented to crush the reformers, pronounced the doom of his own Imperial house, and handed his land over to an alien people.

Dr. Jaisohn maintains that foreign influence was mainly responsible for the destruction of the Independence Club.  Certain Powers did not wish Korea to be strong.  He adds: 

“The passing of the Independence Club was one of the most unfortunate things in the history of Korea, but there is one consolation to be derived from it, and that is, the seed of democracy was sown in Korea through this movement, and that the leaders of the present Independence Movement in Korea are mostly members of the old Independence Club, who somehow escaped with their lives from the wholesale persecution that followed the collapse of the Independence Club.  Six out of the eight cabinet members elected by the people this year, (1919) were the former active members of the Independence Club.”

Among the Independents arrested was Syngman Rhee.  The foreign community, which in a sense stood sponsor for the more moderate of the Independents, brought influence to bear, and it was understood that in a few days the leaders would be released.  Some of them were.  But Rhee and a companion broke out before release, in order to stir up a revolt against the Government By a misunderstanding their friends were not on the spot to help them, and they were at once recaptured.

Rhee was now exposed to the full fury of the Emperor’s wrath.  He was thrown into the innermost prison, and for seven months lay one of a line of men fastened to the ground, their heads held down by heavy cangues, their feet in stocks and their hands fastened by chains so that the wrists were level with the forehead.  Occasionally he was taken out to be tormented, in ancient fashion.  He expected death, and rejoiced when one night he was told that he was to be executed.  His death was already announced in the newspapers.  But when the guard came they took, not Rhee, but the man fastened down next to him, to whom Rhee had smuggled a farewell message to be given to his father after his death.  His sentence was commuted to life imprisonment.

Lying there, the mind of the young reformer went back to the messages he had heard at the mission school He turned to the Christians’ God, and his first prayer was typical of the man, “O God, save my country and save my soul.”  To him, the dark and foetid cell became as the palace of God, for here God spoke to his soul and he found peace.