box I should have shown you that he was one of the
first then in the House to use the suggestion of blasphemy
against me there. Since then I have never had
any peace until the Monday of this week. Writs
for penalties have been served, and suits of all kinds
have been taken against me. On Monday last the
House of Lords cleared me from the whole of one set,
and, gentlemen, I ask you to-day to clear me from
another. Three times I have been re-elected by
my constituents, and what Sir Henry Tyler asks you
to do is to send me to them branded with the dishonour
of a conviction, branded not with the conviction for
publishing heresy, but branded with the conviction,
dishonourable to me, of having lied in this matter.
I have no desire to have a prison’s walls closed
on me, but I would sooner ten times that, than that
my constituents should think that for one moment I
lied to escape the penalties. I am not indicted
for anything I have ever written or caused to be written.
As my Lord at the very first stage this morning pointed
out, it is no question with me, Are the matters indicted
blasphemous, or are they not blasphemous? Are
they defensible, or are they not defensible? That
is not my duty here. On this I make no comment.
I have no duty here of even discussing the policy
of the blasphemy laws, although I cannot help thinking
that, if I were here making my defence against them,
I might say that they were bad laws unfairly revived,
doing more mischief to those who revive them than
to those whom they are revived against. But it
is not for anything I have said myself; it is not for
anything I have written myself; it is not for anything
I have published myself. It is an endeavour to
make me technically liable for a publication with
which I have nothing whatever to do, and I will ask
you to defeat that here. Every time I have succeeded
I have been met with some new thing. When I first
fought it was hoped to defeat my election. When
I was re-elected it was sought to make me bankrupt
by enormous penalties, and when I escaped the suit
for enormous penalties they hope now to destroy me
by this. I have no question here about defending
my heresy, not because I am not ready to defend it
when it is challenged in the right way, and it there
be anything in it that the law can challenge.
I have never gone back from anything I have ever said;
I have never gone back from anything I have ever written;
I have never gone back from anything I have ever done;
and I ask you not to allow this Sir Henry Whatley
Tyler, who dares not come here to-day, to use you
as the assassin uses the dagger, to stab a man from
behind whom he never dares to face.”