The Grammar of English Grammars eBook

Goold Brown
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 4,149 pages of information about The Grammar of English Grammars.

The Grammar of English Grammars eBook

Goold Brown
This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 4,149 pages of information about The Grammar of English Grammars.

   “And earthly power doth then show likest God’s,
    When mercy seasons justice.”—­Beauties of Shakspeare, p. 45.

[368] Wright’s notion of this construction is positively absurd and self-contradictory.  In the sentence, “My cane is worth a shilling,” he takes the word worth to be a noun “in apposition to the word shilling.”  And to prove it so, he puts the sentence successively into these four forms:  “My cane is worth or value for a shilling;”—­“The worth or value of my cane is a shilling;”—­“My cane is a shilling’s worth;”—­“My cane is the worth of a shilling.”—­Philosophical Gram., p. 150.  In all these transmutations, worth is unquestionably a noun; but, in none of them, is it in apposition with the word shilling; and he is quite mistaken in supposing that they “indispensably prove the word in question to be a noun.”  There are other authors, who, with equal confidence, and equal absurdity, call worth a verb.  For example:  “A noun, which signifies the price, is put in the objective case, without a preposition; as, ‘my book is worth twenty shillings.’ Is worth is a neuter verb, and answers to the latin [sic—­KTH] verb valet.”—­Barrett’s Gram., p. 138.  I do not deny that the phrase “is worth” is a just version of the verb valet; but this equivalence in import, is no proof at all that worth is a verb. Prodest is a Latin verb, which signifies “is profitable to;” but who will thence infer, that profitable to is a verb?

[369] In J. R. Chandler’s English Grammar, as published in 1821, the word worth appears in the list of prepositions:  but the revised list, in his edition of 1847, does not contain it.  In both books, however, it is expressly parsed as a preposition; and, in expounding the sentence, “The book is worth a dollar,” the author makes this remark:  “Worth has been called an adjective by some, and a noun by others:  worth, however, in this sentence expresses a relation by value, and is so far a preposition; and no ellipsis, which may be formed, would change the nature of the word, without giving the sentence a different meaning.”—­Chandler’s Gram., Old Ed., p. 155; New Ed., p. 181.

[370] Cowper here purposely makes Mrs. Gilpin use bad English; but this is no reason why a school-boy may not be taught to correct it.  Dr. Priestley supposed that the word we, in the example, “To poor we, thine enmity,” &c., was also used by Shakespeare, “in a droll humorous way.”—­Gram., p. 103.  He surely did not know the connexion of the text.  It is in “Volumnia’s pathetic speech” to her victorious son.  See Coriolanus, Act V, Sc. 3.

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
The Grammar of English Grammars from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.