All Things Considered eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 212 pages of information about All Things Considered.
Related Topics

All Things Considered eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 212 pages of information about All Things Considered.

Generally, instinctively, in the absence of any special reason, humanity hates the idea of anything being hidden—­that is, it hates the idea of anything being successfully hidden.  Hide-and-seek is a popular pastime; but it assumes the truth of the text, “Seek and ye shall find.”  Ordinary mankind (gigantic and unconquerable in its power of joy) can get a great deal of pleasure out of a game called “hide the thimble,” but that is only because it is really a game of “see the thimble.”  Suppose that at the end of such a game the thimble had not been found at all; suppose its place was unknown for ever:  the result on the players would not be playful, it would be tragic.  That thimble would hag-ride all their dreams.  They would all die in asylums.  The pleasure is all in the poignant moment of passing from not knowing to knowing.  Mystery stories are very popular, especially when sold at sixpence; but that is because the author of a mystery story reveals.  He is enjoyed not because he creates mystery, but because he destroys mystery.  Nobody would have the courage to publish a detective-story which left the problem exactly where it found it.  That would rouse even the London public to revolution.  No one dare publish a detective-story that did not detect.

There are three broad classes of the special things in which human wisdom does permit privacy.  The first is the case I have mentioned—­that of hide-and-seek, or the police novel, in which it permits privacy only in order to explode and smash privacy.  The author makes first a fastidious secret of how the Bishop was murdered, only in order that he may at last declare, as from a high tower, to the whole democracy the great glad news that he was murdered by the governess.  In that case, ignorance is only valued because being ignorant is the best and purest preparation for receiving the horrible revelations of high life.  Somewhat in the same way being an agnostic is the best and purest preparation for receiving the happy revelations of St. John.

This first sort of secrecy we may dismiss, for its whole ultimate object is not to keep the secret, but to tell it.  Then there is a second and far more important class of things which humanity does agree to hide.  They are so important that they cannot possibly be discussed here.  But every one will know the kind of things I mean.  In connection with these, I wish to remark that though they are, in one sense, a secret, they are also always a “secret de Polichinelle.”  Upon sex and such matters we are in a human freemasonry; the freemasonry is disciplined, but the freemasonry is free.  We are asked to be silent about these things, but we are not asked to be ignorant about them.  On the contrary, the fundamental human argument is entirely the other way.  It is the thing most common to humanity that is most veiled by humanity.  It is exactly because we all know that it is there that we need not say that it is there.

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
All Things Considered from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.