of resemblance, much less of coincidence.  We can make but the briefest reference to the points of contrast and unlikeness between the two things, after asserting that they have no one common feature.  It might seem evasive in us to suggest to our English critics that they should refresh their memories about the causes and the justification of our Revolution by reading the pages of their own Burke.  We are content to rest our case on his argument, simply affirming that on no one point will it cover the alleged parallelism of the Southern Rebellion.

The relations of our States to each other and to the Union are quite unlike those in which the Colonies stood to England.  England claimed by right of discovery and exploration the soil on which her Colonies here were planted, though she had rival claimants from the very first.  A large number of the Colonists never had any original connection with England, and owed her no allegiance.  Holland, Sweden, and other countries furnished much of the first stock of our settlers, who thought they were occupying a wild part of God’s earth rather than a portion of the English dominions.  The Colonies were not planted at public charge, by Government cost or enterprise.  The English exiles, with but slender grounds of grateful remembrance of the land they had left, brought with them their own private means, subdued a wilderness, extinguished the aboriginal titles, and slowly and wearily developed the resources of the country.  Often in their direst straits did they decline to ask aid from England, lest they might thereby furnish a plea for her interference with their internal affairs.  Several of the Colonies from the first acted upon their presumed independence, and resolved on the frank assertion of it as soon as they might dare the venture.  That time for daring happened to be contemporaneous with a tyrannical demand upon them for tribute without representation.  Thus the relations of the Colonies to England were of a hap-hazard, abnormal, incidental, and always unsettled character.  They might be modified or changed without any breach of contract.  They might be sundered without perjury or perfidy.

How unlike in all respects are the relations of these States to each other and to the Union!  Drawn together after dark days and severe trials,—­solemnly pledged to each other by the people whom the Union raised to a full citizenship in the Republic,—­bound by a compact designed to be without limitation of time,—­lifted by their consolidation to a place and fame and prosperity which they would never else have reached,—­mutually necessary to each other’s thrift and protection,—­making a nation adapted by its organic constitution to the region of the earth which it occupies,—­and now, by previous memories and traditions, by millions of social and domestic alliances, knit by heart-strings the sundering of which will be followed by a flow of the life-blood till all is spent,—­these terms are but a feeble setting forth of the relations of these States to each other and to the Union.  Some of these States which have been voted out of the Union by lawless Conventions owe their creation to the Union.  Their very soil has been paid for out of the public treasury.  Indeed, the Union is still in debt under obligations incurred by their purchase.