Stranger (Hilary Duff song)

"Stranger"
Single by Hilary Duff from the album Dignity
Released	May 25, 2007 (Italy) June 24, 2007 (Mexico)[1] July 10, 2007 (U.S.)[2] September 3, 2007 (UK)[3]
Format	CD single, digital download
Genre	Dance-pop
Length	4:10 (album version) 3:16 (single version)
Label	Hollywood
Writer	Hilary Duff, Kara DioGuardi, Vada Nobles, Derrick Harvin, Julius Diaz
Hilary Duff singles chronology
"With Love" (2007) "Stranger" (2007) "Reach Out"
Hilary Duff Australia singles chronology
"Play with Fire" (2007)	"Stranger" (2007)
Remixes cover

"Stranger" is a song written by Hilary Duff, Kara DioGuardi, Vada Nobles, Derrick Harvin and Julius Diaz, and recorded for Duff's third studio album, Dignity (2007). It features elements of Middle Eastern music, particularly that of India, and aspects of Indian culture were incorporated into the accompanying Fatima Robinson-directed music video. Duff said that contrary to rumors, the song was inspired by the strained relationship between her parents and not by her ex-boyfriend, Joel Madden. Internet feedback from Duff's fans led to the release of "Stranger" as the third single from Dignity in North America, where it was released in July 2007 (see 2007 in music). It was a number-one club hit in the United States, but it became Duff's lowest peaking song on the Billboard Hot 100 chart. In the United Kingdom, where "Stranger" was the album's second single, a WaWa-produced remix of the song was released in September 2007.^[3]

Subject

The song was rumored to be about Duff and her relationship with her ex-boyfriend, Joel Madden;^[4][5][6] Entertainment Weekly wrote, "When the fairy-tale romance between [Duff and Madden] went belly-up late last year, the Good Charlotte frontman speedily rebounded into the twiglike arms of Nicole Richie, and the world moved on. Duff, it seems, did not, and hell hath no fury like a young woman scorned."^[7] According to Duff, the song is actually about how she thought her mother feels around her father, who had an extramarital affair with another woman. Duff said she wrote "Stranger" to appear to be about one of her own relationships, because she didn't want people to know about the strained relationship between her parents.^[6] "But I've realized that so many people can relate to what I've gone through", she said. Another song on the album, "Gypsy Woman", was inspired by the same situation.^[6] Duff told Access Hollywood that writing the song "was like therapy, you know. Just a total release of all the things you hold inside".^[8]

Critical reception

A writer for BBC Radio 1 gave the song three stars, commenting on how it "continues the more grown-up, serious side of Hilary Duff"; he called the vocals "definitely more in the ballpark of 'husky' rather than 'impressive'" and said the Eastern sound owed much to songs such as the Pussycat Dolls' "Buttons". Although he stated he would prefer "Danger", another song on Dignity, to be a single, he said "Stranger" "[wouldn't] sound out of place on a Britney Spears album, which suggests to me that she's done a passable job of leaving behind her bubblegum past", and that it made him "[do] a fair bit of seat-dancing".^[9] A review from Music Focus called the track "unashamedly pop" and said that it was "one of the strongest cuts from Duff's latest album and pushes her into a maturer pop sound". They gave the song a positive review, adding that "Stranger" "need[ed] to be a success" and was "cool, confident slice of dance pop and some of Duff's best work to date".^[10] Gary Lancaster of TeenSpot gave the song four stars, calling it an "example of how a modern pop anthem really should sound". He also called it "sleek and sophisticated" and a "catchy, chart worthy track".^[11] The song was well-received by Billboard reviewer Chuck Taylor, who called it "uptempo" and "dance-friendly", but said that "Top 40 is a tough call".^[12] Blender magazine included the song in the "Dangerously in Love" category on its year-end "Oh Yeah... 209 Songs We Like" list.^[13]

Single release and chart performance

In mid April 2007, in a post on Duff's blog, she told her fans that they could vote for what they thought should be the next single from Dignity.^[14] According to a later post, fan feedback via votes was "overwhelmingly" in favor of "Stranger" as the next single.^[15] Duff promoted the song with performances on Jimmy Kimmel Live, TEENick and So You Think You Can Dance.^[16][17] In mid-2007, concurrent to the preparation of the radio release of "Stranger", Duff was featured in a bikini on the July covers of the magazines Us Weekly and Shape, and on the August cover of Maxim accompanied by the declaration that she had gone "from the queen of teen to breakout sex symbol".^[18] The Associated Press wrote that the first two were representative of "a clear move [on Duff's part] to put her Lizzie McGuire past behind her", and that more provocative imaging of her would help her singles to garner mainstream radio play: "Ultimately, nature, time and genetics may help Duff in a way Disney, despite all its might, cannot."^[18] Guy Zapoleon, a radio consultant and former programmer for top 40 radio, said such imaging would "definitely have a positive effect on the attitude of programmers, who are mostly male, as Disney tries to mature her image".^[18] The single was released to U.S. mainstream contemporary hit radio stations on July 10 2007.^[2] It reached number ninety-seven on the U.S. Billboard Hot 100 to become Duff's lowest peaking song on the chart, on which it spent one week.^[19][20] By August 22, it had reached number eighty-two on the U.S. Mediabase Top 40 radio chart.^[21] The single reached number eighty-six on the Canadian Hot 100,^[20] and as of August 4, it had reached number ninety-seven on the Canadian Mediabase Top 40 radio chart.^[22] "Stranger" received frequent airplay in U.S. nightclubs, peaking at number one on the Billboard Hot Dance Club Play chart—it was Duff's third entry on the chart, and her second consecutive number-one single.^[19][23] On the year-end Hot Dance Club Play Tracks chart, it was ranked thirty-ninth.^[24] "Stranger" entered the Italian Singles Chart at number six (its peak position) in late June. The song peaked at number 139 on the Euro 200 chart and reached the top five in Bulgaria. The WaWa club mix of the song was premiered at the opening party of the Ibiza nightclub Space, which named it "Single of the Week" in its weekly podcast,^[3] and it was issued as a promotional single. It was made available on the UK iTunes Store on June 25 as an album-only purchase. The UK single release of "Stranger" was to be on July 9, according to FemaleFirst.co.uk,^[25] but it was moved back to August 20 to allow the remix to gain airplay in clubs,^[26] and then to September 3,^[3] when it received a download-only release. "Stranger" debuted at 196 on the UK Singles Chart.^[27] In Australia, the song was the third most-added to radio in the week ending October 24;^[28] it entered the Australian ARIA Singles Chart on November 12 at number sixty-eight on download sales alone.^[29] In Canada, "Stranger" is included on the MuchMusic compilation album MuchDance 2008.^[30] Jody den Broeder, who remixed Rihanna's 2007 single "Umbrella", provided a club mix for the song.

Music video

The video for the single was directed by Fatima Robinson and shot in Los Angeles, California, including at a mansion in Silver Lake, between May 10 and May 12.^[15][31] Duff said she was ill during the shoot, but that it went well because she liked the song and the director; she also said she thought it was her best music video to date.^[31] The video premiered on Yahoo! Music on May 30 2007^[32] and had its "First Look" on Total Request Live on June 6, 2007. It debuted on the show's countdown at number ten on June 11, subsequently rising to number two.^[33] In Canada, in the week beginning June 8, the music video debuted at number twenty-six on the MuchMusic top thirty Countdown,^[34] and has since peaked at number one in the week of August 17.^[35] The video reached number two on MTV Asia's The Pop 10 chart.^[36]

Duff performing a belly dance in the music video, wearing henna and beads.

The video begins with Duff's character running out of her home to look for her romantic partner (played by model Caleb Lane), who drives away. It cuts to her waking up and finding a letter and a bracelet, and then shows Duff watching a woman seducing her partner. At a dinner party, Duff's partner kisses her and then flirts with the other woman. The video cuts to a scene at a lounge where dancers entertain the guests, among whom are Duff's partner and two other men. Duff's partner flirts with one of the dancers. Recurring shots of Duff wearing a hooded jacket are edited into the video. The second verse begins with Duff belly dancing^[37] in a harem costume and wearing Indian henna tattoos and beads; according to Duff, they took several hours to apply and reflected the "Indian type beat" in the song.^[31] During the second chorus, the dinner party scene is shown again. Duff is introduced to the other woman, and she talks to other guests. The chorus plays again with Duff walking into a nightclub and teasing her partner, before dancing with another man. She then breaks into another dance routine with two other dancers. The final two choruses show Duff and her partner fighting, and Duff looking at a cellphone before leaving the house with a suitcase. Bill Lamb of About.com named it the week's "Friday Fun Video", writing "Visually, this is probably Hilary Duff's best video yet."^[38] Blender magazine wrote, "Her dancing skills are still a tad stilted but she makes up for it with some key "despondent" and "perturbed" acting faces", also noting what it described as "shameless close-ups of a certain cell phone".^[37] The Sun editorialized, "Nope this isn't the next big Bollywood star—it's Hilary Duff taking her image to a whole new level. The singer's reinvention from squeaky teen star to sexy pop starlet is obviously well underway [...] all well and good for Hilary—just as long as she doesn't do a Britney."^[39] For the WaWa mix of the song, a slightly altered version of the video was released. The music video was added to the iTunes Store in late July 2007.

Track listing

Official remixes and versions

1. "Stranger" (Vada mix) – 4:21
2. "Stranger" (Albert Castillo club mix) – 6:47
3. "Stranger" (Albert Castillo radio edit) – 3:51
4. "Stranger" (Bermudez & Preve Neon mixshow edit) – 4:38
5. "Stranger" (Bermudez & Preve Neon radio edit) – 3:30
6. "Stranger" (Jody den Broeder 86 club mix) – 7:28
7. "Stranger" (Jody den Broeder 86 edit) – 4:04
8. "Stranger" (Jody den Broeder Royal dub) – 8:07
9. "Stranger" (Smax & Thomas Gold remix) – 8:50
10. "Stranger" (Smax & Thomas Gold dub) – 8:34
11. "Stranger" (WaWa remix) – 7:07
12. "Stranger" (WaWa dub) – 6:19
13. "Stranger" (WaWa radio mix) – 3:11
14. "Stranger" (Vission Solmatic mix) – 6:22
15. "Stranger" (Richard Vission vs Dave Audé club mix) – 6:05
16. "Stranger" (Richard Vission vs Dave Audé One dub) – 5:20
17. "Stranger" (Richard Vission vs Dave Audé mixshow) – 5:36
18. "Stranger" (Richard Vission vs Dave Audé edit) – 3:22
19. "Stranger" (radio edit) – 3:16
20. "Stranger" (original edit) – 3:22
21. "Stranger" (UK radio edit) – 3:08

Charts

See also

• Number-one dance hits of 2007 (USA)

Notes