BookRags.com Literature Guides Literature
Guides
Criticism & Essays Criticism &
Essays
Questions & Answers Questions &
Answers
Lesson Plans Lesson
Plans
My Bibliography Periodic Table U.S. Presidents Shakespeare Sonnet Shake-Up
Research Anything:        
History | Encyclopedias | Films | News | Create a Bibliography | More... Login | Register | Help


Semantic Antinomy [Grk AntinomíA ‘Conflict Of Laws’]

Print-Friendly  Order the PDF version  Order the RTF version
About 1 pages (172 words)
Paradox Summary

Bookmark and Share Questions on this topic? Just ask!

Routledge Dictionary of Language and Linguistics

semantic antinomy [Grk antinomía ‘conflict of laws’] (also semantic paradox)

Contradictory statement(s) whose truth value cannot be determined. Compare, for example, the semantic antinomy from classical times about the (lying) Cretan, who maintained: All Cretans are liars. This statement is true only when it is false. Such a logical contradiction can be resolved through the distinction of different linguistic levels ( object language vs metalanguage) which both occur in this example; the assertion of the Cretan that All Cretans are liars creates an impermissible statement about one’s self, which can only be resolved in the object language assertion All Cretans are liars and in the metalinguistic judgment of this assertion: namely, that it is not true. ( also formal logic, type theory)

References

Brendel, E. 1992. Die Wahrheit über den . Berlin and New York.

Kripke, S. 1975.

Outline of a theory of truth. JP 72.690–716.

Levi, D.S. 1988. The liar parody. Philosophy 63.43–62.

Martin, R. (ed) 1970. The paradox of the liar. New Haven, CT.

Tarski, A. 1956. Logic, semantics, metamathematics. Oxford.

This is the complete article, containing 172 words (approx. 1 page at 300 words per page).

View More Summaries on Paradox

Ask any question on Paradox and get it answered FAST!
Answer questions in BookRags Q&A and earn points toward
discounted or even FREE Study Guides and other BookRags products!
Learn more about BookRags Q&A
Copyrights
Semantic Antinomy [Grk AntinomíA ‘Conflict Of Laws’] from Routledge Dictionary of Language and Linguistics. ISBN: 0-203-98005-0. Published: 12-03-1998. ©2009 Taylor and Francis. All rights reserved.



Join BookRagslearn moreJoin BookRags


About BookRags | Customer Service | Report an Error | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy