Shogun Essay | Critical Essay #2

Shogun Critical Essay #2

An American educator and historian, Smith has written widely on Japanese history and was the editor of Learning from "Shogun": Japanese History and Western Fantasy (1980). In the following essay, Smith relates Clavell's sources and manipulation of Japanese culture and history in Shogun.

When confronted with an extremely popular modern novel which is based on histoncal themes the first instinct of the historian, naturally enough, is to ascertain the 'historicity' of the work. The models for the major characters in James Clavell's Shogun are easy to recognize but Clavell has considerably rearranged and refashioned the events and personalities of the time about which he writes.

These changes can be summarized briefly. The model for Blackthorne, the protagonist of Shogun is Will Adams (1564-1620), the circumstances of whose arrival in Japan in April 1600 as pilot of a Dutch ship correspond closely to those of Blackthorne Blackthorne's eventual rise...
(read more)