Annabel Lee Essay | Critical Essay #3

Annabel Lee Critical Essay #3

In this essay, Reilly disputes the contention of Buford Jones and Kent Ljungquist that Frances

Sargent Osgood's poem "The Life-Voyage. A Ballad" served as the model for Poe's "Annabel Lee. "

Professors Buford Jones and Kent Ljungquist exercise more ingenuity than care in arguing that there are enough "internal parallels alone" to make Frances Sargent Osgood's "The Life-Voyage. A Ballad" a "probable model" for "Annabel Lee" [see "Poe, Mrs. Osgood, and 'Annabel Lee,'" Studies in the American Renaissance (1983)]. Noting that Poe must have been familiar with "The Life-Voyage" when he wrote "Annabel Lee," Jones and Ljungquist cite what they believe are five "parallels" between the two poems: 1) both contain the phrase "sounding sea"; 2) both "are ballads"; 3) both "begin in fairy tale fashion beside the sea"; 4) both present a fair maiden "who is envied by the angels in heaven"; and 5) both share the...
(read more)