Ansley, Tracy T. Review of Firegold. Book Report (September-October 1999): 58. This review emphasizes the novel's appeal to young adults and commends the author's realistic world-building.

Duncan, Melanie C. Review of Firegold.

School Library Journal (June 1999): 126.

This short review reflects some of the same tone of drama and mystery found in the novel. Attributes the big change in Jonathon's life to his father bringing home the Dalriada horse.

Koelling, Holly. Review of Firegold. Booklist (May 15, 1999): 1690. This favorable review praises the novel's symmetry and points out the matched conflicts between the Braes and their neighbors and between the two cultures. Calls the illustrations "static and unnecessary" and questions the rapid changes in Jonathon's relationship with his father.