The potential for discussion of The Avatar is almost limitless. It is a joy to read, filled as it is with mystery and wonder, and its depiction of the majesty and beauty of the universe is worthy of thought and speculation. How does the novel capture a distinctive vision of the universe and humanity's place in it? What seems to be Anderson's fundamental conception of the universe? Is it complete? What is missing? What should Anderson take into account? Many novels portray humanity as a small, insignificant aspect of the universe. For instance, Arthur C. Clarke's 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968; see separate entry) portrays humanity as subject to the whims of forces far beyond its comprehension. Does The Avatar do the same? According to the novel, what is humanity's relationship to the universe? Do the schemes of Quick and the daring of Brodersen matter at all?

Another...