Summary:
Illegal immigration is taking its toll on all aspects of the environment. The fires, litter, polluted water, and abandoned automobiles are detrimental to our natural habitats and wildlife. Illegal immigration must be curved in order to save the United States wildlife and natural resources effectively.
Illegal Immigration and the Environment
Linda Sanders
Axia College of University of Phoenix
COM/120 Effective Persuasive Writing
Aimee Styers
July 9, 2006
Illegal Immigration and the Environment
One of the most controversial political issues of today is illegal immigration. Illegal immigration describes the long-term shift of populations across national borders without complying with the legal requirements. Many people are crossing the United States borders illegally to find better jobs, escape political persecution, and to help out families back home. Some Americans are against this movement of immigrants. One problem is because of the damaging effects to the United States environment, another is the amount of money needed to clean up the waste that is being left behind. Illegal immigration not only hurts the economy, it is also taking its toll on the environment. Illegal immigration damages the environment when the illegal immigrants build fires, litter, pollute our natural water sources, and abandon their automobiles.
Illegal immigration damages the environment when the immigrants set up camp and build fires. In the Coronado National Forest, wildfires have been started due to campfires set by illegal immigrants because they do not properly put out the campfires. (Clarren, 2006) The forest has lost many trees including douglas firs and oaks that will take countless years to be replenished. Wildfires have also destroyed 68,413 acres of natural land and cost American tax payers $5.1 million to fight. (Associated Press, 2002) The campfires are also started with brush and vegetation that is harmful to breathe. (Clarren, 2006) Small children and the elderly get respiratory infections as a result of the smoke from these illegal campfires. Jesse Juen field representative of the Bureau of Land Management of Tuscan, Arizona states "Over the past two years wildfires have destroyed about 20% of vegetation along the San Pedro River in Cochise County." (Hull, 2002)
The illegal immigrants are also damaging the environment by leaving litter at their campsites as they travel on. The government has estimated that one immigrant leaves behind eight pounds of litter on the journey. (Davis, 2005) Smugglers make the immigrants leave their belongings so they can get more people into cars and trucks for the trip. The illegal immigrants dump their belongings in favor of nicer clothes to better blend in with the communities where they will be staying. (Davis, 2005) The trash left behind can consist of harmful waste including food cans, plastic bottles, various medications, paper waste, batteries, cell phones, radios, and fecal matter. The Tohono O'odham tribe has used $100,000 in government funds and $30,000 of the tribes own money to remove 40 tons of waste from 84 different places in 2005.(Davis, 2005) In 2005, the city of Tuscan, Arizona allotted $46,000 from their budget to buy a dump truck to carry off waste left behind by illegal immigrants. The money also paid for signs in English and Spanish to identify dumping sites, also gloves, visors, safety vest, and containers for people to clean up the sites. (Davis, 2005) The litter can be very damaging and dangerous to our natural wildlife and natural resources. The litter is also harmful to people as well. The government has estimated that 2000 tons of waste is what immigrants dump each year. (Davis, 2005) What makes migrant waste a problem is that waste is scattered in remote areas where it is dangerous, difficult, and expensive for garbage crews to reach and pick up. (Davis, 2005) Congress has given The Bureau of Land Management $1.3 million during the past two years to restore damage to the land and to clean up waste left behind by immigrants. (Di Rosa, 2004)
Illegal immigration is also threatening our natural water resources. Immigrants use our natural water resources as a place to bathe and to dispose of their human waste. The immigrants have fouled the few water sources in the Sonoran Desert on the Arizona-Mexico border, to the point where it is too filthy for even the wildlife to drink. (Marshall, 2004) In the areas where the water is clean enough for animals to drink, they are unable to because the immigrants are crowding out the water sources. (Reese, 2003) The runoff from the debris left after the illegal immigrants move on is also running into the natural water supply of many animals. The rivers used for human toilets are also very unclean. The toxins from human waste may cause diseases such as typhoid and dysentery. Plants are also unable to reach their full growing capacity when their only water supplies are being polluted or depleted by the illegal immigrants. In southern California, potable water is becoming precious; there are only limited amounts of potable water. People have to import potable water because it is getting scarce. There is pressure to build even more pipelines to bring water from greater distances. (Reese, 2003) This greatly needed water is being used up and polluted by the illegal immigrants.
The United States natural wildlife is being harmed as a result of illegal immigration. There are eight National Wildlife Refuges in the United States totaling 1.1 million acres that share 153 miles of border with Mexico. (Di Rosa, 2003) One of the most harmful problems is the litter left behind that is ingested by our wildlife. Fish are also in danger when the water is polluted or depleted by the illegal immigrants. Medicine bottles and soiled diapers are just two of the examples that have made living impossible in some areas for the wildlife. Illegal dumping is unattractive, unhygienic, and unsafe to cattle and wildlife. Cattle have been found dead with balls of plastic in their stomach that has been determined as their cause of death. The way a cow's stomach is structured, litter such as plastic, becomes stuck in the stomach and is unable to be digested as a result. (Davis, 2005) The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is finding itself increasingly preoccupied with international border security. (Di Rosa, 2003) " The wildlife service has had to adapt its activities in response to the increased focus on homeland security issues in order to more effectively fulfill its mission on conserving wild plants, animals, and habitats" said Roger Di Rosa of the Cabeza National Wildlife Refuge. Mike Coffeen, a biologist with the Fish and Wildlife Service in Tuscan, Arizona, is quoted as saying while surveying the area by airplane: "the level of impact on the wildlife is just shocking." (Di Rosa, 2003) The food litter is such a problem it causes rodents. When coyotes or any other type of animal come into contact with any prescription or over-the-counter medications left behind, these are going to hurt and possibly kill the wildlife. When the water containers break down, and water spills out, it becomes a parasite problem." (Davis, 2005) A report from July, 2002 states that the Bureau of Land Management ask for $23.5 million the first year to help with the illegal immigration problems. The Bureau of Land Management wants to completely put into practice a five-year plan, the cost for this is estimated at $62.9 million. This is not an unreasonable sum to pay out to protect our fragile border parks, national monuments, and wildlife refuge areas against damage done by the illegal immigrants, and to prevent additional loss of our wildlife. (Hull, 2002)
Abandoned automobiles left by illegal immigrants have also become a growing problem on the environment. In the Sonoran Desert alone, Fred Patton, the Chief Ranger at Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument collects over 30 abandoned vehicles a year. (Marshall, 2004) Hundreds of bicycles and smuggling vehicles have been abandoned and tires, batteries, gas cans and seats scattered across the landscape. Abandoned and often burned vehicles are difficult and costly to remove and extreme care is needed to avoid further damage by the removal. (Bureau of Land Management, 2005) Many of the vehicles needing to be removed from the desert are often found to be stolen. Bicycles began to emerge as a significant item in 2003 and some use may stem in transporting drugs, as well as humans. There have been 1725 bicycles removed from the Sonoran Desert. (BLM, 2005) Even though hundreds of abandoned vehicles have been removed from the national parks, hundreds still wait to be removed. 300 vehicles have been removed from the Bureau of Land Management Lower Sonoran Field Office and 341 vehicles have been removed from Southern Arizona Bureau of Land Management lands. (BLM, 2005) Abandoned vehicles are also a source of hazardous materials.
Illegal immigration is taking its toll on all aspects of the environment. The fires, litter, polluted water, and abandoned automobiles are detrimental to our natural habitats and wildlife. Illegal immigration must be curved in order to save the United States wildlife and natural resources effectively. This controversial subject applies to all Americans and can happen in anyone's back yard. The illegal immigration epidemic is a growing problem in the United States and without additional awareness to this problem; the environment and the natural wildlife could be permanently damaged or endangered with irreversible consequences. President Ronald Reagan once said "A nation without borders is not a nation." (Hull, 2002)
Word Count: 1495
References
Associated Press. September 9, 2002 Illegal Immigrants Tied to Costly Wildfires. May 31, 2006
www.usinfo.stste.gov
Clarren, Rebecca. (May 24, 2006). A silent victim of illegal immigration is our public lands.
June 6, 2006. The Vail Trail. www.vailtrail.com
Davis, Tony. (August 24, 2005). Trash woes piling up. June 1, 2006. Arizona Daily Star.
www.azstarnet.com
DiRosa, Roger. (June 17, 2004). Cabeza National Wildlife Refuge. May 31, 2006. US Senate
Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee. www.usinfo.state.gov
Hull, Diana. (June 27, 2002). Environmental Damage at the Arizona - Mexico Border and
Intrusion into the Lives of Americans Living There. June 1, 2006. Desert Invasion
www.desertinvasion.us.html
Marshall, Bob. (March 15, 2004). Violent Drama Plays Out Amid Natural Splendor.
May 31, 2006 Newhouse News Service. www.usinfo.state.gov
McFarlin, Sheila. Southern Arizona Project. (April 24, 2006). Mitigate Environmental Damages
Resulting from Illegal Immigration. Tucson, Arizona: Bureau of Land Management. Reese, April. (February 13, 2003). Immigration Taking Toll on Parks, Refugees near U.S.
Mexico Border. May 31, 2006. Environment and Energy Publishing. www.usinfo.state.gov
This is the complete article, containing 1,677 words
(approx. 6 pages at 300 words per page).
