be removed at so critical a time unless the government
were prepared to fill his place with one of equal,
if not superior capacity. A general, to hope
for success, must have the confidence and respect
of his troops. To remove one who has, and fill
his place with one who has not, is a crime than which
none can be greater. It is a crime against the
brave men whose lives are at the risk of the capacity
of their commander. Our government committed
this crime when it gave the command of the army of
the Potomac to General Burnside. That general
was the best judge of what he could do, and freely
confessed his incapacity for so high a command.
But the government was not to be put off by this confession
of weakness on the part of a general, preferring to
reward him for his honesty, and make no account of
his capacity. I accept this, my son, as the only
reason why General Burnside was given so high a command.
As for his capacity as a general, he gave us a proof
of that when he let the rebels fall back, and get
well fortified at Fredericksburg. To show, however,
what a general could do by attempting impossibilities,
he sent the brave army of the Potomac to be slaughtered
by an enemy covered with stone walls. I tell you,
my son, it was a dark day for the nation when that
was done. It multiplied our misfortunes, gave
a deeper wound to our grief and sorrow, and brought
disgrace on our arms.
I will pass over these misfortunes as lightly, my
son, as possible, hoping only that they will serve
us as a warning in the future. Having buried
Burnside deep under the misfortunes of his own incapacity,
the question again came up, where shall we find a
general to do up these rebels for us, and gain us a
little victory? The great Grant was doing wonders
for us in the West. He was bold, earnest, and
brave. And this was the secret of his success.
But in the East we were sorely troubled for some one
who could do something.
General Hooker was brave and bold. But, my son,
he had such a weakness for blowing his own trumpet.
Yes, he could blow it as loud and as long as any trumpeter
you ever listened to—Pope excepted.
He had declared of himself that he was just the man
to lead our army to victory, and give the enemy a
sound thrashing. It was true, this general had
been very insubordinate. He had said a number
of things, neither wise nor polite, of his superiors.
And he had set an example to his soldiers not inclined
to improve their discipline. As, however, he
had declared himself the man to lead our army to victory,
and the government wanted just such a man, it took
the general at his word, and gave him the command.