the violence and dissimulation of the Romans, as described
by Livy, induced him to inculcate the principles on
which they acted. The scientific method followed
by Aristotle in the Politics encouraged him in the
adoption of a similar analysis; while the close parallel
between ancient Greece and mediaeval Italy was sufficient
to create a conviction that the wisdom of the old
world would be precisely applicable to the conditions
of the new. These, however, are exculpations of
the man rather than justifications of his theory.
The theory was false and vicious. And the fact
remains that the man, impregnated by the bad morality
of the period in which he lived, was incapable of ascending
above it to the truth, was impotent with all his acumen
to read the deepest lessons of past and present history,
and in spite of his acknowledged patriotism succeeded
only in adding his conscious and unconscious testimony
to the corruption of the country that he loved.
The broad common-sense, the mental soundness, the humane
instinct and the sympathy with nature, which give
fertility and wholeness to the political philosophy
of men like Burke, are absent in Machiavelli.
In spite of its vigor, his system implies an inversion
of the ruling laws of health in the body politic.
In spite of its logical cogency, it is inconclusive
by reason of defective premises. Incomparable
as an essay in pathological anatomy, it throws no
light upon the working of a normal social organism,
and has at no time been used with profit even by the
ambitious and unscrupulous.
CHAPTER VII.
THE POPES OF THE RENAISSANCE.
The Papacy between 1447 and 1527—The Contradictions
of the Renaissance
Period exemplified by the Popes—Relaxation
of their hold over the
States of the Church and Rome during the Exile in
Avignon—Nicholas
V.—His Conception of a Papal Monarchy—Pius
II.—The
Crusade—Renaissance Pontiffs—Paul
II.—Persecution of the
Platonists—Sixtus IV.—Nepotism—The
Families of Riario and Delia
Rovere—Avarice—Love of Warfare—Pazzi
Conspiracy—Inquisition in
Spain—Innocent VIII.—Franceschetto
Cibo—The Election of Alexander
VI.—His Consolidation of the Temporal Power—Policy
toward Colonna and
Orsini Families—Venality of everything
in Rome—Policy toward the—
Sultan—The Index—The Borgia
Family—Lucrezia—Murder of Duke
of Gandia
Cesare and his Advancement—The Death of
Alexander—Julius II.—His
violent Temper—Great Projects and commanding
Character—Leo X.—His
Inferiority to Julius—S. Peter’s
and the Reformation—Adrian VI.—His
Hatred of Pagan Culture—Disgust of the
Roman Court at his
Election—Clement VII.—Sack of
Rome—Enslavement of Florence.