When the first flush of his excitement had passed, Felix, thinking over the scene of the morning as he took his horses down to water at the stream, became filled at first with contempt, and then with indignation.  That the first commander of the age should thus look on while the wall was won before his eyes, and yet never send a strong detachment, or move himself with his whole army to follow up the advantage, seemed past understanding.  If he did not intend to follow it up, why permit such desperate ventures, which must be overwhelmed by mere numbers, and could result only in the loss of brave men?  And if he did permit it, why did he not, when he saw they were overthrown, send a squadron to cover their retreat?  To call such an exhibition of courage “a main of cocks”, to look on it as a mere display for his amusement, was barbarous and cruel in the extreme.  He worked himself up into a state of anger which rendered him less cautious than usual in expressing his opinions.

The king was not nearly so much at fault as Felix, arguing on abstract principles, imagined.  He had long experience of war, and he knew its extreme uncertainty.  The issue of the greatest battle often hung on the conduct of a single leader, or even a single man-at-arms.  He had seen walls won and lost before.  To follow up such a venture with a strong detachment must result in one of two things, either the detachment in its turn must be supported by the entire army, or it must eventually retreat.  If it retreated, the loss of prestige would be serious, and might encourage the enemy to attack the camp, for it was only his prestige which prevented them.  If supported by the entire army, then the fate of the whole expedition depended upon that single day.

The enemy had the advantage of the wall, of the narrow streets and enclosures within, of the houses, each of which would become a fortress, and thus in the winding streets a repulse might easily happen.  To risk such an event would be folly in the last degree, before the town had been dispirited and discouraged by the continuance of the siege, the failure of their provisions, or the fall of their chief leaders in the daily combats that took place.

The army had no discipline whatever, beyond that of the attachment of the retainer to his lord, and the dread of punishment on the part of the slave.  There were no distinct ranks, no organized corps.  The knights followed the greater barons, the retainers the knights; the greater barons followed the king.  Such an army could not be risked in an assault of this kind.  The venture was not ordered, nor was it discouraged; to discourage, indeed, all attempts would have been bad policy; it was upon the courage and bravery of his knights that the king depended, and upon that alone rested his hopes of victory.

The great baron whose standard they followed would have sent them assistance if he had deemed it necessary.  The king, unless on the day of battle, would not trouble about such a detail.  As for the remark, that they had had “a good main of cocks that morning,” he simply expressed the feeling of the whole camp.  The spectacle Felix had seen was, in fact, merely an instance of the strength and of the weakness of the army and the monarch himself.