British Folk-Music Settings Nr. 4, "Shepherd's Hey" eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 199 pages of information about British Folk-Music Settings Nr. 4, "Shepherd's Hey".

British Folk-Music Settings Nr. 4, "Shepherd's Hey" eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 199 pages of information about British Folk-Music Settings Nr. 4, "Shepherd's Hey".
the audience, and even the critic, is tempted to judge life in terms of the play instead of judging the play in terms of life.  Thus falsely judged, The Wild Duck (to take an emphatic instance) is outrageously immoral, although it must be judged moral by the philosophic critic who questions only whether or not Ibsen told the truth about the particular people involved in its depressing story.  The deeper question remains:  Was Ibsen justified in writing a play which was true and therefore moral, but which necessarily would have an immoral effect on nine spectators out of every ten, because they would instinctively make a hasty and false generalisation from the exceptional and very particular ethics implicit in the story?

For it must be bravely recognised that any statement of truth which is so framed as to be falsely understood conveys a lie.  If the dramatist says quite truly, “This particular leaf is sere and yellow,” and if the audience quite falsely understands him to say, “All leaves are sere and yellow,” the gigantic lie has illogically been conveyed that the world is ever windy with autumn, that spring is but a lyric dream, and summer an illusion.  The modern social drama, even when it is most truthful within its own limits, is by its very nature liable to just this sort of illogical conveyance of a lie.  It sets forth a struggle between a radical exception and a conservative rule; and the audience is likely to forget that the exception is merely an exception, and to infer that it is greater than the rule.  Such an inference, being untrue, is immoral; and in so far as a dramatist aids and abets it, he must be judged dangerous to the theatre-going public.

Whenever, then, it becomes important to determine whether a new play of the modern social type is moral or immoral, the critic should decide first whether the author tells lies specifically about any of the people in his story, and second, provided that the playwright passes the first test successfully, whether he allures the audience to generalise falsely in regard to life at large from the specific circumstances of his play.  These two questions are the only ones that need to be decided.  This is the crux of the whole matter.  And it has been the purpose of the present chapter merely to establish this one point by historical and philosophic criticism, and thus to clear the ground for subsequent discussion.

OTHER PRINCIPLES OF DRAMATIC CRITICISM

I

THE PUBLIC AND THE DRAMATIST

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
British Folk-Music Settings Nr. 4, "Shepherd's Hey" from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.