Prairie Oyster's third album,
Everybody Knows, was released in 1991. The album featured four top 10 singles in Canada: "Did You Fall In Love with Me," "One Precious Love," "Will I Do (Till the Real Thing Comes Along)" and "Everybody Knows." Unfortunately, only one single charted in the U.S., "One Precious Love" (#51). Prairie Oyster won several CCMA Awards in
1992, including Album of the Year for
Everybody Knows, Song of the Year for "Did You Fall In Love with Me," as well as their third straight win as Group or Duo of the Year. The Juno Awards also awarded them Country Group or Duo of the Year for the fourth time. The band's fourth album,
Only One Moon, was released in Canada on
Arista Records in
1994. It would also go on to become their most successful. The first single, "Such a Lonely One," was also their first #1 in Canada. Two more singles released from the project also reached the top of the Canadian Country chart, "Don't Cry Little Angel" and the title track. Additional singles "Louisiette," "Black-Eyed Susan" and "Ancient History" all reached the top 10. They were named Group or Duo of the Year by the CCMA in 1994,
1995 and
1996, and won the Bud Country Fans' Choice Award in 1994. The Juno Awards also recognized Prairie Oyster as the Country Group or Duo of the Year in both 1995 and 1996. Their fifth album,
Blue Plate Special, was released in 1996. The first song released from the disc, "Unbelievable Love," reached #1. "One Way Track" was also a top 5, but follow-up singles peaked outside the top 10.
Bohdan Hluszko replaced Bruce Moffat as the drummer on the album. The following year, Hluszko was fired from the band after coming out as
transgendered.
[6] With the
1998 release of their sixth album,
What is This Country, the group returned to the top 10 with the songs "Canadian Sunrise" (#5) and "Keep On Dreaming (#9). Charlie Cooley filled in as drummer for the band. Cooley is the father of Canadian actor
Ryan Cooley. The band released their first
greatest hits album,
String of Pearls, in
2000. The only song released from the project was "Man in the Moon," which had been re-recorded as a duet with
folk singer-songwriter Jenny Whiteley. Prairie Oyster re-surfaced in
2006 with the release of their latest album,
One Kiss, on
Open Road Recordings. So far the album has produced three singles, "Sweet Sweet Girl to Me" (written and originally recorded by
Don Gibson), "Too Bad For Me," and a cover of
Bob Dylan's "I Threw It All Away."