In the following review, Kreider asserts that, despite its superficial sweetness and light tone, The Straight Story reveals a dark undercurrent of alcoholism and family abuse.

In the following essay, Cardullo praises The Straight Story for its restraint and serenity, asserting that it is one of the greatest films ever made.

In the following review, Kauffmann praises The Straight Story as “a small epic” that embodies the American ideal of rugged individualism.

In the following review, Jackson characterizes The Straight Story as blandly sweet.

In the following review, Simon praises The Straight Story for its gentle tone and refreshing simplicity, noting that despite its sentimentality, the film avoids becoming sappy.

In the following review, Sterritt comments on the dark undertones beneath the superficial sweetness of The Straight Story.

In the following review, Tayler praises Lynch's restrained cinematic style in The Straight Story.