Pete Townshend Critical Essay | Critical Essay by Chris Welch

Critical Essay by Chris Welch

Since the [Who's] inception they have been bedevilled by ideas that haven't quite come off, by schemes that haven't always worked out, and by a confused battle for real acceptance.

While they have a tremendous image, the public, hardcore fans apart, have tended to regard the Who as either amusing or scandalous, but never musically valid.

The ideas of Peter Townshend, Roger Daltrey, John Entwistle and Keith Moon have been smothered in a fog of feuding, and a clutter of broken amplifiers and blitzed drums.

Occasionally some of their musical promise has come through on the odd A or B side, while their first album ["The Who Sings My Generation"] was frankly a disappointment.

But ["A Quick One"] is a collection of compositions and treatments that captures the Who essence, humour, cynicism, nervous drive, violence, and delicacy….

Pete's musical achievement [to date is "A Quick One While He's Away"]—a sort...
(read more)