In Comstock Lode L'Amour tells, obviously, the story of people caught up in the great silver rush that played such an important part in this nation's history. If some of the writing is flat, and some of the characters incomplete or contradictory, well much the same can be said of life itself.
It is, in fact, pointless to discuss either the merits or weaknesses of L'Amour's writings, both of which abound, since it will have little or no effect on either the author or his public, which covers all ages, sexes, and intellectual areas. Suffice to say that the books do exactly what their creator intends. They present a historically accurate picture in an entertaining and informative manner of people facing a great challenge. Thus, while he may never be the subject of learned discourse in a creative writing class, it is not inconceivable that future generations may look to Louis L'Amour for guidance to the pathways of the past in history and sociology. Certainly he provides these lessons in a more energetic and painless way than, say, James Michener, to whom the comparison is more apt than many might think.
Steve Berner, "Tales of L'Amour," in Lone Star Review (copyright © 1981 Lone Star Review, Inc.), Vol. 3, No. 3, May, 1981, p. 10.
This is a free excerpt of 214 words. There are 218 words (approx.
1 page at 300 words per page) in the full critical essay.
Read the rest of this Criticism with our L'Amour, Louis 1908?–: Critical Essay by Steve Berner Access Pass.
