[The Magicians of Caprona] is a sprightly, pleasant, ingenious book, but it is neither as strong nor as multi-layered as Charmed Life; the author seems here, as in her other recent work, to be marking time….
Neither the rivalry between the families nor the threat of defeat generate much tension. Only in the fifth chapter, when Tonino and Angelica, captives of an evil enchantress, are forced to act out a degrading Punch and Judy show for their captor's sadistic amusement, does the action rise to any pitch of excitement or suspense. Otherwise, it is light-hearted fun, played out against a rather ready-made, stagey background, written with flair but without penetration.
This is a free excerpt of 109 words. There are 147 words (approx.
1 page at 300 words per page) in the full critical essay.
Read the rest of this Criticism with our Jones, Diana Wynne 1934–: Critical Essay by Neil Philip Access Pass.
