When Yvor Winters's publisher and friend Alan Swallow hailed him in 1940 as the "sage of Palo Alto," he accurately touched on the paradox of Winters's career: the isolation in which he became admired ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Delmore Schwartz
[The essay from which this excerpt is taken was originally published in The Southern Review, Vol. 3, No. 3, 1938.]
Mr. Yvor Winters has written [Primitivism and ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Denis Donoghue
It is my understanding that the figure the story makes is crucial in the definition of Mr. Winters's work; what it marks is not merely one theme among many. Mr...
Read more
Critical Essay by W. W. Robson
I cannot admire [Forms of Discovery]. It does not seem to me, as a whole, either sound literary history or sound criticism. Clearly Winters is not a writer like W. P. K...
Read more
Critical Essay by W. W. Robson
[Yvor Winters: Uncollected Essays and Reviews] contains about forty essays and reviews by Yvor Winters which he did not republish in book form…. I found the coll...
Read more
Critical Essay by Grosvenor Powell
[The essay from which the following excerpt is taken was originally published in a slightly different form as "Two Essays: 'Quantity and the Meters of...
Read more
Critical Essay by Elizabeth Isaacs
"Yvor Winters: poet, professor, critic …" This original sequence still holds when one turns from critical theory to actual practice in the deve...
Read more
Critical Essay by Randall Jarrell
Maule's Curse, which is supposed to relate "the history of ideas (a history of ideas that, neglecting both science and philosophy, is almost wholly the...
Read more
Critical Essay by John Crowe Ransom
[The essay from which this excerpt is taken originally appeared in The Southern Review, Summer 1940.]
The critic who is best at pouncing upon the structure of a...
Read more
Critical Essay by R. P. Blackmur
[The essay from which this excerpt is taken was originally published in Poetry, November 1940.]
What is most valuable about Yvor Winters as a critic is just what i...
Read more
Critical Essay by Robert Daniel
As the title [of The Anatomy of Nonsense] is somewhat too cumbrous for convenience, perhaps we should use a short form of it, in the manner of the newspaper Variety. T...
Read more
Critical Essay by Cleanth Brooks
[Yvor Winters] is not amiable, not charming, obviously very earnest, and willing to split a hair to any distinguishable degree of fineness. Moreover, he exhibits all ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Randall Jarrell
["In Defense of Reason"] is a particularly good book to buy; one can put it between Empson's "Some Versions of Pastoral" and Eliot...
Read more
Critical Essay by William Barrett
[In a] general sense Yvor Winters is one of the philosophical critics, and his work may be taken to illustrate both the difficulties and the dangers of the critical ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Don Stanford
It should be remembered … that Winters is a poet as well as a critic. His critical theories derive from his experience in writing poetry; his application of thes...
Read more
The American Classics: A Personal Essay, by Denis Donoghue. Yale University Press, 295 pages, $27.Rapping the knuckles of the American classics is good fun-especially if it's done with a light, sha...
Read more