Critical Essay by George Dangerfield
The armaments industry is a subject which fiction does well to take up; and Mrs. Caldwell's attack [in Dynasty of Death] is handled with the patience and s...
Read more
Critical Essay by Nona Balakian
[In] "The Wide House" Miss Caldwell has begun to question her formula. She has discovered that "a man might find some kindliness ∗ ∗...
Read more
Critical Essay by Richard A. Cordell
Taylor Caldwell's long, turbulent narratives—one appears every year with the regularity of the almanac or year-book—are very much alike. From...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary Mcgrory
Will "There Was a Time" cause a rift between Taylor Caldwell and her everloving public? Will that public … mind that she has slapped their wrists i...
Read more
Critical Essay by William Soskin
Taylor Caldwell realizes full well the limitations and stupidities of her Melissa [the heroine of Caldwell's "Melissa"], daughter of a philosophi...
Read more
Critical Essay by Charles Lee
What will America be like in 1970? Miss Caldwell's [apocalyptic "The Devil's Advocate"] makes Spengler seem cheerful by comparison. In this n...
Read more
Critical Essay by Riley Hughes
Up to now Miss Caldwell has been in the habit of simplifying the past, of building her plot and bullying her characters around one idea…. In The Devil's A...
Read more
Critical Essay by Granville Hicks
If critics took the author of "Never Victorious, Never Defeated" as seriously as she takes herself, articles would have long since appeared on "...
Read more
Critical Essay by Harrison Smith
[Taylor Caldwell] has pursued through sixteen novels almost every aspect of the rise of those multi-millionaire families in the United States Theodore Roosevelt calle...
Read more
Critical Essay by Jane Cobb
It is impossible to read anything of Taylor Caldwell's without being reminded of the old gag, "He don't sing good, but he sings loud." Miss Cal...
Read more
Critical Essay by Virginia Kirkus' Service
In choosing to put emphasis on the early life of Luke the physician, Taylor Caldwell has presented [in Dear and Glorious Physician] quite a different...
Read more
Critical Essay by Halford E. Luccock
[In Dynasty of Death the] author avoids one ready pitfall of the long family-history novel, that of sacrificing everything to breadth and length. There is a stret...
Read more
Critical Essay by Caroline Tunstall
St. Luke, author of the third Gospel and of the Acts, was with St. Paul in Rome and is referred to by him as "the beloved physician." According to tr...
Read more
Critical Essay by Charles Lee
Spacious, alive with the bustle of ancient times and places, and illumined by flashes of genuine lyrical intensity, "Dear and Glorious Physician" is the pr...
Read more
Critical Essay by Riley Hughes
On page 572 (the final page) [of Dear and Glorious Physician] Miss Caldwell adds this sentence (in parentheses) after her own final sentence of the novel: "Conti...
Read more
Critical Essay by Charles Lee
Taylor Caldwell is an angry woman. She tells us so in a candid foreword to her curious new novel ["The Listener"]. Man does not need a new religion, she sa...
Read more
Critical Essay by Riley Hughes
The Listener is not exactly a novel; it is rather a series of related episodes or tales held together by a slender string of place. The protagonists of these episodes c...
Read more
Critical Essay by Martin Levin
When love comes to Caroline Ames Sheldon in Taylor Caldwell's "A Prologue to Love" …, it is page 553, and there are only sixty pages or so t...
Read more
Critical Essay by Annette T. Rottenberg
The natural perversity of students can sometimes be turned to good account, as when a student asks (apropos of a discussion about reading habits), "But ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Edith Farr Ridington
[A Pillar of Iron] is a long and pretentious novel about Cicero which I found extremely annoying both because of its many inaccuracies (I made note as I read of...
Read more
Critical Essay by William B. Hill
[A Pillar of Iron is an] astonishingly powerful novel based on the life of Cicero. Miss Caldwell obviously admires the great orator, practically making him a pre-Chr...
Read more
Critical Essay by Anthony Boucher
["Dialogues with the Devil"] is an exercise in moral indignation without the mechanics of fiction that customarily camouflage Miss Caldwell's op...
Read more
Critical Essay by Harold Strauss
["The Eagles Gather"] continues the saga of the Bouchard family, the great armaments clan whose fortunes were first set forth in "Dynasty of Deat...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
A conversation with the Devil presents a fairly obvious literary temptation, especially perhaps to a Christian, but to anyone who plans to discuss the ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Publishers Weekly
No question, [Taylor Caldwell] … can tell an engrossing story. She proves it once again in ["Captains and the Kings," a] gigantic novel about ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Duncan Fallowell
Until about three quarters of the way through [Captains and the Kings] I more or less knew what I should be writing about. Now I am not so sure. It seemed to be one...
Read more
Critical Essay by Best Sellers
Big, wordy, sprawling, ["Captains and the Kings"] is probably a thesis novel; there is some loose association with the Kennedy family, though in this inst...
Read more
Critical Essay by Martin Levin
Return with Taylor Caldwell to ancient Greece [in "Glory and the Lightning"], where characters in desperation are wont to cry: "Wine, in the name o...
Read more
Critical Essay by Martin Levin
"But you can't marry me! You are—Jeremy Porter—a rich man and a lawyer, and I am only a servant girl!" So says Ellen Watson, a beauti...
Read more
Critical Essay by Barbara Sicherman
Ceremony of the Innocent is well written, but the plot remains unconvincing. This time the notion of a small group secretly controlling the world is implausible. T...
Read more
Critical Essay by Publishers Weekly
The prolific and best selling Caldwell collaborates with [Jess Stearn in I, Judas], retelling the Judas Iscariot story from an angle that's unusual if not n...
Read more
Critical Essay by Glenn Mayer
The collaboration of Taylor Caldwell and Jess Stearn on their second novel, I, Judas, has resulted in an exceptionally interesting work….
Judas is depicted not...
Read more
Critical Essay by Pat Gold
[Taylor Caldwell's Bright Flows the River] is anti-establishment, anti-feminist, anti-democracy, anti-family, anti-power, anti-duty, and in fact anti almost everythi...
Read more
Critical Essay by Clifton Fadiman
Taylor Caldwell's "Dynasty of Death" succeeded in making munitions manufacturers seem considerably more dramatic than they probably are in actua...
Read more
Critical Essay by Anne Marie Stamford
After thirty-two novels it's good to see that Taylor Caldwell hasn't lost her touch. Her superb style of storytelling turns the ordinary theme of B...
Read more
Critical Essay by Kirkus Reviews
Although there's no dearth here of Caldwell's portable sermonettes on such evils as soft living, [Answer As a Man, a] turn-of-the-century Pennsylvania t...
Read more
Critical Essay by Richard Freedman
Taylor Caldwell is a shining exemplar of Grey Power, still churning out highly successful novels in which she loftily pretends the 20th century—at least in f...
Read more
Critical Essay by Richard A. Cordell
["Dynasty of Death" and its recently-published sequel, "The Eagles Gather,"] have the same theine—the titanic struggle between ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Clifton Fadiman
Taylor Caldwell's "The Earth Is the Lord's" … reminds one less of a novel than it does of a particularly grandiloquent opera. All ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Louise Maunsell Field
For the background of her new novel, "The Strong City," Taylor Caldwell has chosen the town of "Nazareth," Pa., and the steel indus...
Read more
Critical Essay by Herbert Gorman
While "The Arm and the Darkness" by Taylor Caldwell is primarily a long narrative of the physical and spiritual struggles of a young nobleman during the...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Miss Taylor Caldwell casts her net wide in search of themes and periods for the sort of elaborate fiction she favours…. Nobody need or should de...
Read more