Mary Noel Streatfeild called herself a misfit in the vicarage family of her birth. In more than eighty children's and adults' books, however, she often drew on an imaginative, rebellious girlhood. Bor...
Read more
Critical Essay by Phyllis Bentley
Too much of Parson's Nine reads like E. M. Delafield's Diary of a Provincial Lady with the wit left out. The Reverend David Thurston's wife stru...
Read more
Critical Essay by Joan Macwillie
Pauline, Petrova and Posy Fossil are three little foundlings who laugh and work their way through the Academy of Dancing and Stage Training [in "Ballet Shoes...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
["Ballet Shoes"] gradually shapes itself into an interpretation of the nature of a dramatic artist's talents as well as a detailed description...
Read more
Critical Essay by Jane Spence Southron
In spite of the similarity of some of the subject-matter, "Caroline England" is in every way far ahead of Miss Streatfeild's previous novel...
Read more
Critical Essay by George Dangerfield
Readers of fiction are now pretty familiar with the theme of the decay of an English upper middle class family. It is a pleasure to report that Miss Streatfeild...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Lamberton Becker
I do like a book that takes me into a family—one that I like—in the first chapter. Before it is over in ["Tennis Shoes"] I not only ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
The 10 to 14 year-olds who learned about the training of London stage children in Noel Streatfeild's original and entertaining "Ballet Shoes" ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
Noel Streatfeild has the faculty of taking her readers backstage with an ease which gives them the feeling of first-hand experience whether it be in a dramatic sch...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Lamberton Becker
["Circus Shoes"] will entertain the family. Noel Streatfeild began as a writer of fiction for adults; the success of her first story for children,...
Read more
Critical Essay by Irene Smith
Among children's books there has always been extra space for the literature of the circus, so [Circus Shoes] takes its natural place with a welcome from all sides...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
The ten to fourteen year old readers who enjoyed "Circus Shoes" and Noel Streatfeild's earlier books are due for a shock with ["The Sec...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
At the beginning of ["Parson's Nine"] one has fears that its subject will be the dismal life of a parson's wife, worn out w...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Lamberton Becker
The English author who rolled up an American public by lively stories of young folks working and playing in ballet shoes, tennis shoes and circus shoes, widens ...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Lamberton Becker
The preceding "Shoes" stories lifted Miss Streatfeild into the first rank of contemporary children's authors. "Theater Shoes,"...
Read more
Critical Essay by Dorotha Dawson
[Theater Shoes is another] spirited and charming story that compares well in style [with the popular Ballet Shoes]…. Vivid and interesting details of stage tra...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Lamberton Becker
Any one who has sent, perhaps at some personal sacrifice, a parcel of new wearing apparel to some one in England during the war, and then suddenly realized that...
Read more
Critical Essay by Josephine E. Lynch
[Party Shoes] describes in detail the preparations for and many characters involved in giving a pageant. Details may become boring to many readers, although Strea...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
More tightly knit than most of Miss Streatfeild's stories, ["Party Shoes"] has also the sense of theatre glamour and family activity which has...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ellen Lewis Buell
One of the most engaging qualities about the children in Noel Streatfeild's stories is that they have their normal quota of human frailty. It is a debatable...
Read more
Critical Essay by Louise S. Bechtel
From many angles ["Movie Shoes"] is the best of the popular "shoes" books for "middle age" young American readers. Here t...
Read more
Critical Essay by Naomi Lewis
With its Cinderella-in-the-film-studios motif [The Painted Garden, British title of Movie Shoes] should be wildly popular, and cause considerable juvenile discontent...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Like not a few novels of its kind, Mothering Sunday deals with present day matters without always conveying the sense that the author is, in fact, thin...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Christian Science Monitor
Simple in plot and construction, ["The Parson's Nine"] is, nevertheless, delightfully readable. The author possesses to a remarkab...
Read more
Critical Essay by Peter J. Mcdonnell
["Mothering Sunday"] is told with a deft and economical hand. Precisely chosen conversational tidbits and natural actions are used in place of descr...
Read more
Critical Essay by Marjory Stoneman Douglas
[The Caldwell children in "Mothering Sunday"] had neglected their mother and would have gone on neglecting her if someone had not reported tha...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
The sad thing about [White Boots] is that it does not ring true, and that is disappointing from the writer who made that strange story of the Fossils (in Ballet...
Read more
Critical Essay by Louise S. Bechtel
The "shoes" [in "Skating Shoes," the American title of "White Boots"] are those of young professional skaters. Lalla, the...
Read more
Critical Essay by Nancie Matthews
[In "The Picture Story of Britain," an] excellent and sensible book, Noel Streatfeild never talks down. She serves up hard facts about the United Kingd...
Read more
Critical Essay by Louise S. Bechtel
[In "The Picture Story of Britain"], a famous author does a good job for a prospective traveler of about twelve to fifteen…. [The text covers]...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
The idea of taking children through the door of history and introducing them to the past is by no means new, but Miss Streatfeild's manner of performing ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Claire Huchet Bishop
["The First Book of the Ballet"] is for girls and their parents who are fortunate enough to live not too far from a good teacher. It is the story ...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Miss Streatfeild's story of the vicissitudes of the Bell family in their Rectory in South-East London [The Bell Family] is based on a radio serial which ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Naomi Lewis
The rarest good books are about ordinary life today; one must admire, therefore, the expert hand behind The Bell Family—a particularly pleasant reminder of the na...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Nobody knows the stage child better than Miss Streatfeild; and [in Tops and Bottoms] her picture of Bobbie drafting his father's Era advertiseme...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary Welsh
From the very first page [of "Family Shoes," American title of "The Bell Family"] we are immediately in [the Bells' house, sharing thei...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[The Circus Is Coming (British title of "Circus Shoes") contains] rapid, lively pictures of the life of the circus. The men, the circus children a...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[In Wintle's Wonders] Miss Streatfeild has given us another gay and lively work peopled by a centre group of vivid personalities, while her intense inter...
Read more
Critical Essay by Virginia Kirkus' Service
I'm afraid the pattern is growing thin [in Dancing Shoes, U.S. title of Wintle's Wonders] after Ballet Shoes, Movie Shoes, Theatre Shoe...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margaret Sherwood Libby
The "Shoes" series, of which ["Dancing Shoes"] is the sixth, is greatly enjoyed by girls of eleven or so, and "Dancing Sho...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margaret Sherwood Libby
["Queen Victoria"] will hold young people's interest from beginning to end. It not only gives the outward facts of Victoria's lif...
Read more
Critical Essay by Virginia Kirkus' Service
To any adult who recalls with delight Noel Streatfeild's Parson's Nine, many years ago, this juvenile story of a clergyman's fam...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Miss Streatfeild can write a masterly, sentimental tear-jerker of a story better than anyone, but New Town [British title of New Shoes] is by the doyenne of mod...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
By far the most successful theatre stories for children are those which, with children as their subjects, can show rivalries and ambitions unaffected, as yet, by the ...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
A new book by Noel Streatfeild is always something to which we look forward. Since the days of Ballet Shoes she has concerned herself with families where the ch...
Read more
Critical Essay by The New York Times Book Review
Not the least interesting incidents and episodes [in "Tops and Bottoms"] are those dealing with [Beaty's gradual transformation f...
Read more
Critical Essay by Zena Sutherland
The atmosphere of the artistic and musical world [in Traveling Shoes, U.S. title of Apple Bough] is vivid, the children are sophisticated but completely convincing; ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Marcus Crouch
The most skilful, sincere and honest writer of [career-books]—and she was much more besides—was Noel Streatfeild…. Ballet Shoes [1936] established...
Read more
Critical Essay by Nora E. Taylor
["A Vicarage Family"] is an autobiography written as a story. Mostly it comes off very well, though every once in a while the impersonality becomes too ...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Miss Streatfeild's account of a childhood spent in an Edwardian vicarage [A Vicarage Family] has the genuine flavour of a period piece. She writ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ruth Hill Viguers
The common denominator of [Streatfeild's books for children] and the quality that lifts even the lesser ones out of the realm of the ordinary is the sense o...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Possibly no one but Miss Noel Streatfeild could have carried off the outrageous plot of The Children on the Top Floor with such an air of insouciant pl...
Read more
Critical Essay by Barbara Ker Wilson
All Noel Streatfeild's stories for children reflect something of her vivid memory of her own childhood, her consciousness of the way of life in which she w...
Read more
Critical Essay by Carolyn Heilbrun
Twenty-seven years ago when there was no television but only books and the loneliness of long afternoons, I read "Ballet Shoes" by Noel Streatfeild. T...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Christian Science Monitor
Miss Streatfeild brings to "The Children on the Top Floor" the good characterization and inside knowhow about children's careers t...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
[Away from the Vicarage, the continuation of Noel Streatfeild's autobiography,] describes her attempt to break away from the restriction of her ...
Read more
Critical Essay by E.b.c. Jones
Sarah, the would-be governess, when we first meet her [in Shepherdess of Sheep] is a chattering girl of nineteen, common, commonsensical, and far from engaging. She car...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ruth Hill Viguers
Vicky's adventures and attitudes [in On Tour] represent what many considered typical of young women of the period. The novel is the author's own stor...
Read more
Critical Essay by Zena Sutherland
[On Tour is] just as enjoyable as the author's description of her childhood; here the account of the Strangeways family is picked up at the end of World War I...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Miss Streatfeild, with her good background knowledge of ballet and theatre, makes an excellent guide to the young opera-goer. Unfortunately, [Enjoying Opera] is...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The Growing Summer, which inverts the idea that children really want a ruleless, clockless, back-to-the-primitive life, shows Miss Streatfeild in excel...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The very young reader to whom Noel Streatfeild addresses her Enjoying Opera is not likely to be lured to the opera house by the potted history of opera...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Dr. Gareth goes to the East for a year leaving his wife and family behind. They are the traditional suburban family of "literature"; the odd thing...
Read more
Critical Essay by Barbara Wersba
["The Magic Summer," American title of "The Growing Summer"] is a charming book, and also an empty one. Something has gone very wrong.
...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Tim, the central character [of Caldicott Place], is one of Miss Streatfeild's most attractive: he does the opposite to what the adults suggest, with exce...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
Noel Streatfeild's characters are built on a simple principle, one dominant trait for each. The central figure of Caldicott Place … has a certain bounce...
Read more
Critical Essay by Zena Sutherland
[The Family at Caldicott Place, American title of Caldicott Place] has a few contrivances and a pat ending; it also has several situations of great appeal: the integ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margaret Cheney Dawson
It might seem on the face of it that a book describing faithfully and affectionately the life of a large English household, and especially the days and ways o...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
Noel Streatfeild has written few stories more pertinent than this study of young Harriet and her career as a champion ice-skater [White Boots]. The fierce pressure of...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Noel Streatfeild's position in the children's book world is unique. She has had all the accolades…. Her first children's bo...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[Margaret Thursday] is a forthright, determined extrovert with a life of her own apart from the story [of Thursday's Child]. her words and actions are a ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Muriel Hutton
[Thursday's Child is a] substantial book of absorbing fiction, among so many puffed up with secondary virtues. 'After Dickens' in its wealth of in...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary M. Burns
Although the setting and situations [of Thursday's Child] are in the turn-of-the-century tradition of "orphan stories," the heroine is a remarkabl...
Read more
Critical Essay by Sandra Paxford
[All Streatfeild's characters] have one thing in common—security. This security need not come from your own parents or relatives, but from someone who i...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Beyond the Vicarage is the last volume of Noel Streatfeild's autobiographical trilogy. It is also probably the most significant, since it deals ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Isabel Quigly
[In 1936 came Ballet Shoes,] a children's book still loved nearly two generations later, in which [Streatfeild's] gift for immediacy and solidity was use...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[Beyond the Vicarage] is written with objectivity, using the device of writing in the third person. It is an honest book which, while it answers many of the que...
Read more
Critical Essay by Lois E. Savage
"Beyond the Vicarage" deals with surface details of a life that should be exciting and stimulating. The book is neither. Too many words are used to reco...
Read more
Critical Essay by Louise Maunsell Field
No person at all familiar with English novels is in the least likely to envy the lot of the English governess. The difficulties and hardships of her life have ...
Read more
Critical Essay by May Hill Arbuthnot and Zena Sutherland
Noel Streatfeild's Shoes books are all vocational in their themes, but they manage to avoid the heavy earnestness that generally pervad...
Read more
Critical Essay by Valerie Alderson
[In When the Siren Wailed] Noel Streatfeild has written about evacuees from London…. In the end, of course, everything works out all right, but there is a th...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Times remembered are often only real to those with whom we remember them, and it is not easy to bring them to life for others. The children in [When the Sirens ...
Read more
Critical Essay by B. J. Martin
However young the reader of [A Young Person's Guide to Ballet], the interest can always be accompanied by awareness. I wish, therefore, that Noel Streatfeild had...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[A Young Person's Guide to Ballet] has been written with the ordinary child in mind, the one who wants to learn to dance, with the result that some balle...
Read more
Critical Essay by Heidi Von Obenauer
I wish when I were around nine or ten, someone had given me this book to read. Like all other children who dream of dancing, I was ripe for a book which viewed th...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary Cadogan
[In Far to Go] Noel Streatfeild skilfully conveys the stringent professionalism of the serious theatrical child: she communicates the total involvement behind the scene...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary Cadogan and Patricia Craig
The well-chaperoned child star of impeccable propriety had been a feature of American film studios as far back as the early 1900s; but it was not unt...
Read more
Critical Essay by Denise M. Wilms
The happy ending Streatfeild fashions [in When the Sirens Wailed, U.S. title of When the Siren Wailed] could be called contrived, but it's satisfying—e...
Read more
Critical Essay by Zena Sutherland
Some of the terminology [in When the Sirens Wailed] will be unfamiliar to readers (the wartime trains "is something chronic," a woman complains) but ca...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
"Ballet Shoes" is a children's novel of the theatre written by somebody who knows all about stage training and little girls, apart...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
After forty years in the field Noel Streatfeild, incredibly, can still tell a story with the same glow and the same sturdy common-sense beneath the sparkle. Far...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
A Vicarage Family [is] the first of three fictionalised autobiographies … which give Noel Streatfeild's many readers, young as well as adult, an insight...
Read more
Critical Essay by Bob Dixon
Since girls in general are so severely conditioned and repressed and so turned in upon themselves, they fall victims to fantasies in consequence. In Noel Streatfeild...
Read more
Critical Essay by Christine Mcdonnell
[As a child,] Ballet Shoes enveloped me. I entered the world of the three Fossils completely, sharing their classes, performances, and everyday routines. (p. 191...
Read more
Critical Essay by Benny Green
Meanwhile, back in [Nesbitshire], nothing has changed. The parson still lives at the Rectory, whose boards are still trodden by our old pals of the Edwardian Repertory P...
Read more