Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
As may be expected from [Mollie Hunter, The Kelpie's Pearls] is blended from the folk lore of the countryside, the commonsense of Morag—the old wo...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Mollie Hunter, in The Ghosts of Glencoe, gives fictional treatment to an historical event, and one of which every detail has already been closely studi...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The perils of scoffing at the fairy world are … brought home hard to Thomas the blacksmith [in Thomas and the Warlock]. A story in the true Gael...
Read more
Critical Essay by Kirkus Service
[A Pistol in Greenyards is a] tale within a tale: the first an evocation of an 1854 estate eviction (Highland Scots), the second a frame for writing the experiences...
Read more
Critical Essay by Edward Fenton
The point of view [of A Pistol in Greenyards] is noble and humanitarian. Unfortunately, the style is so pedestrian, the dialogue so stilted and the characters so black...
Read more
Critical Essay by Diane G. Stavn
[The Ferlie is an] overly long but nevertheless intriguing fantasy with authentic characters, setting and dialect…. The old question of the desirability of per...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The detail [in The Ferlie] is right, both human and traditional. The narrative moves in the proper traditional way. But ultimately the story lacks in t...
Read more
Critical Essay by John Signoriello
[In The Lothian Run, sixteen]-year-old Sandy Maxwell, a bored and restless apprentice in a law office in Edinburgh, Scotland in the early 18th Century, is afforded ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Zena Sutherland
[The Lothian Run is a] romantic adventure story with an element of mystery and some meaty historical background. Few writers today are more skilled in this genre tha...
Read more
Critical Essay by Kirkus Reviews
[The Walking Stones is a very light fantastic, deftly tripped story that seems to tell itself, to unfold] with no more of a prod than the turn of a page and the sures...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
It takes a remarkable writer to push Mollie Hunter into second place. Here is that rarest of beings, the born story-teller…. The Bodach [British...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Mollie Hunter's The Kelpie's Pearls is something of a triumph, for fantasy and magic are made to appear natural and inevitable in a moder...
Read more
Critical Essay by Jane Yolen
Subtitled "a novel of suspense," The Walking Stones is not really a mystery tale. Rather, in a deeper sense, this story of the flooding of a Highland glen b...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
The author has a strong feeling for fantasy and an ability for setting the atmosphere for magic and uncanny happenings. In all her books there is only a narrow ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Gordon Parsons
It is only the high standard that Mollie Hunter's earlier novels has established that makes one express an edge of disappointment over her latest [The Lothian ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Sheryl B. Andrews
Combining in [The 13th Member: A Story of Suspense] the feeling for history found in The Lothian Run … with the proven ability—as in The Kelpie...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The consummate ease with which the background of this unusual and powerful historical novel [The Thirteenth Member] is set masks the author's ca...
Read more
Critical Essay by Robert Nye
In Wales, you have the Tylwyth Teg, a strange and beautiful supernatural race, unfortunately much given to the stealing of children. In Scotland, a similar reputation att...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
The Haunted Mountain does not simply retell an old story, but reworks within the framework of a novel the story of Tam Lane, the man stolen by the fair...
Read more
Critical Essay by Eleanor Cameron
Mollie Hunter's two best books, to my way of thinking, are her second fantasy, "The Kelpie's Pearls," and this, her first novel of realis...
Read more
Critical Essay by Lillian N. Gerhardt
The Child Study Association just gave [A Sound of Chariots] its annual award, but it is difficult to understand why: the pace is infinitesimally slow, the main c...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
Only a poet dares try to convey to the more earthbound of us the emotion he experiences when he sees a rainbow in the sky. A scientist, by reference to...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[The Spanish Letters] is a good cloak-and-dagger, the plot moving at a fast pace, the characters reasonably well-developed for this type of book. There is plent...
Read more
Critical Essay by Jill Paton Walsh
There is a vast gulf, often remarked upon, between the childhoods of actual children, liable like all the rest of us to the fell grip of circumstance, to poverty, a...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[The reference to Andrew Marvell's poem "To His Coy Mistress" in the title of A Sound of Chariots] is apt, for two reasons. First, the them...
Read more
Critical Essay by Susan Cooper
Mollie Hunter's "The Stronghold" takes an enormous leap back in time….
The force of Druidical magic and the mercilessness of tribal ritua...
Read more
Critical Essay by Eleanor Cameron
[With "The Stronghold"] Mollie Hunter has given us a tumultuous yet clearly conceived and tautly constructed novel, narrated in one evoking scene after...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
The Pictish broch, in spite of its likeness to the great Mycenean beehive tombs, is unique in its extraordinarily simple and effective defence-plan, and local enough ...
Read more
Critical Essay by David Churchill
The brutal eviction of the tenant farmers of Greenyards, a valley in the Scottish Highlands, provides the core of this entirely absorbing novel [A Pistol in Greenyar...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mollie Hunter
[It was] at the insistence of my two young sons that I wrote my first children's book, they being much charmed with two short stories I had written for them in ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Robert Bell
Mollie Hunter has already written successful junior novels set in the Orkneys and Shetlands. This latest one [A Stranger Came Ashore] is a product of her study of the Sh...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[A Stranger Came Ashore] is not quite the work expected of a Carnegie winner, but it would make a lesser reputation. The hero is not young Robbie Henderson, who...
Read more
Critical Essay by Kirkus Reviews
[Talent Is Not Enough consists of five] essays based on a 1975 series of lectures in America and ranging from the moral obligations of a writer for children to the op...
Read more
Critical Essay by Gordon Parsons
The 'Caddies', that strange band of beggars and guides that formed a distinctive feature of sixteenth-century Edinburgh, provide an exciting human flavo...
Read more
Critical Essay by Mary M. Burns
[Talent Is Not Enough: Mollie Hunter on Writing for Children] emerges as a major study of the writer's craft, concerned with but certainly not limited to the ar...
Read more
Critical Essay by Paul Heins
Mollie Hunter is best known for her historical narratives and fantasies for young people, but her present essays [collected in Talent Is Not Enough: Mollie Hunter on Writ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Peter Hollindale
Mollie Hunter is by general consent Scotland's most distinguished modern children's writer…. [She] is read with pleasure not only in her own co...
Read more
Critical Essay by Gordon Parsons
The Ghosts of Glencoe embodies most of the strengths that we associate with writing for children of a more confident day—pace, sustained excitement, clearly de...
Read more
Critical Essay by Norman Culpan
[In The Wicked One action] is fast, events are credible and consistent given the magical premises, and a dry humour unobtrusively pervades the whole…. Tone and ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Stanley Cook
It was providence that the book of Mollie Hunter's I read last was A Sound of Chariots. It is the author's answer to the questions that build up in coveri...
Read more
Critical Essay by Geraldine Deluca
A certain simplicity of explanation, an occasional withholding of details—what the heroine's father died of, for instance—identify [A Sound of ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Janet Hickman
Certainly it is hard to imagine how one could bring more of self to writing than [Mollie Hunter] does. Cultural heritage, life circumstances, love of language, passion...
Read more
Critical Essay by Chuck Schacht
The usually reliable [Mollier Hunter's] latest [The Third Eye] can best be compared to haggis, a uniquely Scottish dish made primarily from sheep organs; it may...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
What a fine writer Mollie Hunter is! One might think that, with her preoccupation with the Scottish scene, her stories might slip into monotony, but not a bit; ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Ethna Sheehan
["The Smartest Man in Ireland" is an] exhilarating adventurefantasy with real Irish flavor in the phrasing; and imagination, humor, gaiety and some under...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margaret Meek
The grainy texture of the narrative and the evocation of doom (in the sense of judgement) are excellently done [in The Third Eye].
The action takes place in 1932 wh...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
The Third Eye [is] an extraordinarily vivid and impressive study of a family and a community in a Scottish town in the 1930's. Attention is held from that firs...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
A Pistol in Greenyards confirms the view that, though Mollie Hunter falls short of the magic by which a [Rosemary] Sutcliff or a [Winifred] Bryher turn...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
[A Pistol in Greenyards] is a most vivid account of the tragedy of the Highland Clearances….
This is a most gripping story, the dignity and bravery of...
Read more
Critical Essay by Margery Fisher
For Mollie Hunter, place is as important as people and causes. In The Ghosts of Glencoe she draws an almost unbearably vivid setting for the massacre of 1692—a...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Junior Bookshelf
Despite its inept title, [The Ghosts of Glencoe] is an excellent book, one of the best accounts of the famous massacre. Perhaps being a Scot without being a Cam...
Read more