Critical Essay by Christopher Ricks
Among the things which Coleridge "lamented" about Wordsworth's poetry was that "his genius was not a spirit that descended to him throu...
Read more
Critical Essay by Terrence Des Pres
Criticism in the Wilderness may be the best, most brilliant, most broadly useful book yet written by an American about the sudden swerve from the safety of establi...
Read more
Critical Essay by Denis Donoghue
"Criticism in the Wilderness" is concerned with many of the same questions that troubled its predecessors, but it differs from them in one respect: to a...
Read more
Critical Essay by Frederick Crews
There can be no mistaking the fact that the study of meaning has now been vigorously contested. Some theorists hold that such study is always marred by a simplistic ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Bernard Bergonzi
Hartman's Saving the Text shows him at one and the same time engaging with Derrida, succumbing to him, imitating him and resisting him. His writing is determ...
Read more
Critical Essay by The Times Literary Supplement
To call Professor Hartman's new book Wordsworth's Poetry, 1787–1814 is about as relevant as squeezing the late C. S. Lewis between...
Read more
Critical Essay by Laurence Lerner
[Geoffrey Hartman] doesn't believe that mere brute life can be art. "Forms are a betrayal of life": hence they are necessary. (Mr Hartman calls ...
Read more
Critical Essay by Joseph N. Riddel
Though there is evidence here and there that [Beyond Formalism: Literary Essays 1958–1970] is a kind of housecleaning before a new start, Professor Hartman h...
Read more
Critical Essay by Richard Poirier
[In "The Fate of Reading and Other Essays"], there emerges a consensus view of a possibly coherent theory of poetics. This is … validated by som...
Read more
Critical Essay by Denis Donoghue
The Fate of Reading is a new selection of Geoffrey Hartman's writings, from work published during the past five years. Many essays resume the themes of an earl...
Read more
Critical Essay by Jonathan Culler
[Geoffrey Hartman] repeatedly proves himself a subtle analyst of genres, though he usually prefers to invent or discover his own. Several essays in The Fate of Readi...
Read more
Critical Essay by Donald Marshall
Formalism—called "New Criticism" when it was still young, aggressive, and ambitious—seems to have died from its own success. Any ordinary...
Read more
Critical Essay by Gerald Graff
Insofar as I could discern a thesis in this diffuse book [Criticism in the Wilderness: The Study of Literature Today], I took it to go something like this: Anglo-Americ...
Read more